Monday, July 2, 2018

That Lever

So I was reading a new piece on the Fordham's blog about the newest hot idea in reformsterland-- high quality curriculum-- and there it was again.

The lever.

As I write in a new Brookings Institution report, The challenges of curriculum materials as a reform lever, there are many reasons why districts flunk this basic test.

The lever turns up fairly often. And as a metaphor for education reform policy, it says quite a lot.

A lever is a tool that one uses to force movement. There's nothing collaborative about a lever. And you don't apply a lever from inside the area you want to affect-- you stand outside the box and bear down. If something breaks and snaps loose, it will go flying away from you. 

Leverage is not about partnership-- it's about using tools to impose your will on an object from a distance. You don't climb in there and see what you can do working with the affected area. You don't get your hands in that dirt. You learn the area just well enough to gauge where you can most effectively apply some force. You just keep your distance and apply force through your lever.

This model also assumes that your problem is that things are stuck, that there is some sort on intractable problem that needs to be busted apart. So stuck that the busting should be none too gentle. And a lever is a machine for magnifying force-- in other words, you use a lever when you want to apply more force than you could on your own. 

This has been the story of the worst of ed reform all along. Don't get directly involved. Don't team up with the people on the ground. Assume that schools are stuck in some intractable mess that only brute force can bust apart. Just stay in DC or New York and figure out how you can best apply force at a distance. 

You don't use a lever to help flowers grow. You don't use a lever to ease troubled waters. And most of all, you don't use a lever to solve human problems. You don't use a lever to feed the hungry or comfort the poor or sooth a crying baby. You don't use a lever to teach children. There's very little about education that calls for the exercise of brute force. You don't use a lever to persuade or to promote understanding. You use it to impose your will on an object with no regard or concern for that object, top down, outside in. 

So, Reformsters, the next time you're looking for a metaphor for imposing a policy, consider something other than levers. In fact, take a moment to consider why a lever seems like a good metaphor, and ask yourself if that doesn't suggest some ways you could change your whole approach. Maybe you could pick a better tool than a crowbar. 

1 comment:

  1. Thank you so much, for your perspective on teaching reform. Those who are imposing these reforms claim that they have had a good education, don't they? and Yes, it was without all these reforms.
    And the lever, these new reforms are like clinical trials, without any research to back them up and yet they are forced down the throats of teachers as if the current education system is in such dire for survival. And it is forced down the chain of command, as if those who are in the chain of command, acting like puppets, know what they are actually forcing down. Secondly, before they have actually tried out the crazy reform in its entirety, there comes another crazy reform. I believe it all about someone whom they know trying out his business stunt. They try it for a couple of years and hey, if it doesn't work or if it has messed up the education system, the business has still made it's profit - so WHO Cares!!! - Long term - It has led Teacher harassment and the exodus of teachers. No one wants to be a Teacher, Educational schools have dropped their programs for lack of enrollment and then there are no teachers. this is a classic teachers / educational depression. This is the Education/Business Cycle.
    Education is not a Business. As teachers we deal with children, who have emotions..... not widgets and we cannot apply one size fits all strategies. So if you have a wonderful idea in Educational Reform for profit? Suck it up!!