Thursday, February 12, 2015

What's The Matter With Indiana

In the modern era of education reform, each state has tried to create its own special brand of educational dysfunction. If the point of Common Core related reforms was to bring standardization to the country's many and varied state systems, it has failed miserably by failing in fifty different ways.

What Indiana provides is an example of what happens when the political process completely overwhelms educational concerns. If there is anyone in the Indiana state capitol more worried about education students than in political maneuvering and political posturing, it's not immediately evident who that person might be.

The current marquee conflagration of the moment is the announcement of a new Big Standardized Test that will take twelve hours to complete. This announcement has triggered a veritable stampede from responsibility, as every elected official in Indianapolis tries to put some air space between themselves and this testing disaster. And it brings up some of the underlying issues of the moment in Indiana.

Currently, all roads lead to Glenda Ritz.

Back before the fall of 2012, Indiana had become a reformster playground. They'd made early strides solving the puzzle of how to turn an entire urban school district over to privatizers, and they loved them some Common Core, too. Tony Bennett, buddy of Jeb Bush and big-time Chief for Change, was running the state's education department just the way reformsters thought it should be done. And then came the 2012 election.

Bennett was the public face of Indiana education reform. He dumped a ton of money into the race. And he lost. Not just lost, but looooooooosssssssssst!!! As is frequently noted, Glenda Ritz was elected Superintendent for Public Instruction with more votes than Governor Mike Pence. I like this account of the fallout by Joy Resmovits mostly because it includes a quote from Mike Petrilli that I think captures well the reaction of reformsters when Bennett lost.

"Shit shit shit shit shit," he said. "You can quote me on that."

After Ritz became a Democrat education in a GOP administration, Republican politicians decided that given her overwhelming electoral victory, they'd better just suck it up and find a way to honor the will of the people by working productively with her  to fashion bi-partisan educational policies that put the needs of Indiana's students ahead of political gamesmanship. Ha! Just kidding. The GOP started using every trick they could think of to strip Ritz of her power.

As Scott Elliot tells it in this piece at Chalkbeat, things actually started out okay, with Ritz and the Pence administration carving out some useful compromises. Elliot marks the start of open warfare at Bennettgate-- the release of emails showing that Tony Bennett had gamed the less-than-awesome Indiana school grading system to favor certain charter operators.

Certainly Ritz and pence have different ideas about how to operate an education system. Mike Pence particularly loves charters-- so much so that he has taken the unusual move of proposing that charter schools be paid $1,500 more per student than public schools (so forget all about that charters-are-cheaper business).

Indiana has also created a complicated relationship with the Common Core, legislating a withdrawal from the Core, but one that required the state to do it without losing their federal bribes payments. The result was a fat-free Twinkie of education standards-- not enough like the original for some people and too much like it for others.

The Indiana GOP has been trying to separate Ritz from any power. They cite any number of complaints about her work style and competence (the GOP president of the Senate famously commented "In all fairness, Superintendent Ritz was a librarian, okay?") and most of the complaints smell like nothing but political posturing.

It's understandable that the state Board of Education would be a cantankerous group. Consider this op-ed piece from Gordon Hendry, newest member of the board, Democrat, attorney, business exec, and director of economic development under former Indianapolis mayor and current charter profiteer Bart Peterson. Hendry opens with, "To me, education policy is economic policy" (pro tip, Mr. Hendry-- education policy is education policy). After castigating Ritz for not running pleasant, orderly meetings (because her job is, apparently, to make alleged grownups behave like actual grownups), Hendry works up to this:

As a Democrat, I don't know why the superintendent insists on creating conflict where rational debate should instead exist.

That just sets off the bovine fecal detector into loud whoops. First, we've got an accusation buried as an assumption (she's the one creating conflict). Combine that with playing the feigned ignorance card-- I just have no idea why she could be so touchy! Really, dude? I'm all the way over here in Pennsylvania, and I can tell why she might be involved in some crankypants activity. I'm pretty sure winning an election and being forced to work with people who dismiss you and try to cut you out of power-- I'm pretty sure that would put someone in a bad mood. So I can understand finding her ideas obnoxious and disagreeing with how she runs a meeting, but when you claim her point of view is incomprehensible, that tells me way more about you than about her.

Most of the statements I read coming out of Indiana are like that-- they carry a screaming barely-subtext of "I am just stringing words together in a way that I've calculated might bring political advantage, but I am paying no real attention to what they actual mean to real humans."

I have no idea how good at her job Glenda Ritz actually is, but the political statement represented by her landslide election seems clear enough, and it's a little astonishing that Indiana's leaders are so hell bent on thwarting the will of the electorate. But damned if the legislature isn't trying to strip her of chairmanship of the Board of Education.

Meanwhile, the fat-free Twinkie standards have spawned some massive tumor of a test, coming in at an advertised length of twelve hours which breaks down to A) weeks of wasted classroom time and B) at least six hours worth of frustrated and bored students making random marks which of course gets Indiana C) results even more meaningless than the usual standardized test results although D) McGraw-Hill will still make a mountain of money for producing it. Whose fault is that? Tom LoBianco seems close to the answer when he says, basically, everyone. (Although Pence has offered a gubernatorial edict that the test be cut to six hours, so, I don't know- just do every other page, kids? Not sure exactly how one cuts a test in half in about a week, but perhaps Indiana is a land of miracles.*) But it's hard for me not see Ritz and Indiana schools as the victims of a system so clogged and choked with political asshattery that it may well be impossible to get anything done that actually benefits the students of Indiana.

UPDATE: On February 11, the Senate Education Committee gave the okay to a bill that would exempt voucher schools from taking the same assessment as public schools. In fact, the voucher schools can just go ahead and create a test of their own. It is remarkable that the State of Indiana has not just closed all public schools, dumped all the education money in a giant Scrooge McDuck sized vault, and sold tickets to just go in a dive around in it.

There's going to be a rally at the Statehouse on Monday, February 16th. If I were an Indiana taxpayer-- hell if I were a live human who lived considerably closer-- I would be there. This is a state that really hates its public schools.

* Edit-- I somehow lost the sentence about the shortening of the test in posting. I've since put the parenthetical point back.


  1. Here is the most current educational dysfunction from Kansas: A proposal to pay foster parents with public education money if they home school, but only if they attend church regularly and refrain from drinking, smoking, and extramarital sex (I wonder how they intend to enforce that). There's even a "Leave It To Beaver" reference.

  2. Shitty Loser Bennett (instead of being in jail for campaign irregularities because our state is so ethically-challenged) is now hired by HQE (Hoosiers for Quality Education)- a group you'll find quoted and cited by TNTP (The New Teacher Project) that Pence's appointees brought in to "partner" with the IDOE. Both HQE and TNTP are all about the reform efforts. So it's even worse than you thought. Love your post! As sad and angry as all this makes me, it made me laugh!

  3. Oh I LOVE this post! Thanks for shining the spotlight on our current dysfunction here in Hoosierland. You left out the fact that Monday, during the House hearing in which our state legislature passed the bill to remove Glenda Ritz from her role as chairperson of the state board of ed (HB1409)-- our heroic governor held a news conference announcing that this test (the big fat Twinkie) was too long and he, by order of his supreme leadership, was using an executive order to shorten it. It was, you guessed it, all Glenda Ritz's fault that this test was so long. Unfortunately, unsuspecting parents celebrated his actions and some actually believed him to be saving the day.

    Those of us who have been paying attention, who are parents with kids in school, who worked to help elect Glenda Ritz and who want to stop the destruction of public ed, were not so easily duped.

    You can read my own unedited tirade here

    But more importantly, if you are in Indiana, JOIN US AT THE STATEHOUSE FOR A RALLY. Monday, February 16th at 2pm. Speak up.

    1. I had a line in there about his magical edict but I apparently dropped it in edit. Thanks to you I realized it was gone and pout it back. Thanks. Lovely rant-- I don't know how folks in Indiana are putting up with all this.

    2. As a Hoosier, I'm having a horrible time putting up with this. Consider yourself warned--His Highness Emperor Pence has presidential aspirations.

      I no longer have school aged children. However, what I was taught back in the day of the dinosaur was that if the people did not like what their elected officials were doing, they had the responsibility to vote them out of office. It never occurred to me that OTHER elected officials would simply legislate them out. It's simply appalling.

  4. Also living in Indiana, and it is a flippin' nightmare. There's only so much one can say about crap... so on to other matters. The phrase "bovine fecal detector" is hilarious! Brilliant word choice! 2 thumbs up!

  5. None of these people, except Glenda Ritz, know what is happening inside the classroom. Their necessity of yearly experimenting on children is beyond horrible. Their misguided belief that stricter testing and more charter schools, with vouchers, will solve all problems shows no willingness to learn the scope of the problem. Hope the $2000 a day comes out of Pence's personal pocket. Tax payers shouldn't have to pay for this incompetence by our GOP dominated government.

    INDIANAPOLIS | Gov. Mike Pence has hired a Michigan education consultant at $2,000 per day to recommend ways of reducing the extra-long duration of this year's ISTEP-Plus standardized test -- but the Department of Education doesn't expect he'll find many.

    Edward Roeber has until Feb. 19 to review the exam and offer DOE suggestions for cutting the nearly 12 hours of scheduled testing to something closer to the six hours of ISTEP tests students in grades three through eight took last year.

    "Hoosier families can be assured that we will shorten this test," said Pence, a Republican.

  6. Somehow the information that this quote from a news article published in The Times of NW Indiana on Feb. 11, 2015 got left out.

  7. All this political "bovine fecal matter" is why so many Hoosiers home school.