There is much about the federal voucher program that remains undefined, but we know the basics. It's a tax credit voucher, which means if you've got some money to burn, you can contribute it to funding a school voucher and have that contribution count as paying your taxes. The contribution actually goes to a Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO) in a sleight of move that is supposed to make it look as if taxpayer dollars aren't being diverted to funding private schools, but at least one state supreme court has seen through that baloney.
Evers correctly noted that the federal voucher would be catastrophic for public schools.
The usual fans of dismantling public schools and privatizing the remains did not care for the governor's decision. "Why so fast," said folks at the right wing Badger Institute (a great name which really ought to be associated with something cooler than a bunch of wealthy guys who would like to not pay taxes). "There's lots of time left to decide, and this is like free money!"
It is not. Your brother-in-law owes you a hundred bucks. You send your spouse to collect it because you need it to buy groceries this week, and they return with fifty bucks and a couple of cases of beer. "Did you spend our money on beer?" you ask. "No, my brother just gave me this instead of the other fifty dollars. So this is like, you know, free beer!" Are you convinced? Or are you just out fifty bucks that you needed to feed your family?
The Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce really wants that beer, and they have come up with a whole campaign to sell the federal vouchers. If not to Evers (who is not running for a third term and so doesn't have to care about these guys), then maybe the next governor.
Pay It Forward Wisconsin is the campaign, and it tries hard to make these vouchers look swell. There's a certain amount of creativity here-- the actual rules for federal vouchers haven't been written yet, so some of this pitch might best be considered "aspirational" or "loosely interpretive" or even "made up."
The tax credit allows "you to donate up to $1,700 to the school of your choice." Well, you'll donate it to an SGO, which may or may not be aim that money at a particular school. Some states (like PA) allow any private school to set up its own SGO, and others do not. The law suggests that an SGO has to serve at least two schools; any private schools with multiple campuses could well satisfy that requirement. The federal law suggests that donors can designate the school, but not the student. But that could change when the actual rules are written.
PIFW also suggests that public school students could use the voucher money to fund extras like a tutor or a band trip. Except that, again, the rules haven't been written yet, and no state with vouchers has allowed for this particular use of voucher funds.
PIFW is accepting "pledges" and notes that "If you don’t have a specific school in mind, Pay It Forward Wisconsin will direct your donation to nearby schools serving students in poverty with a proven track record of improving reading and math proficiency," all of which sure makes it sound like PIFW is positioning itself to be an SGO (SGOs get to keep a slice of the voucher pie, so it can be a profitable business to be in).
Who's the face of all this? Dale Kooyenga is a GOP politician who is currently serving as MMAC president and the main mouthpiece for PIFW. He's an accountant and private equity guy, as well as an army reserve lieutenant colonel. When he was in the Wisconsin legislature, he helped push a plan to privatize Milwaukee schools. He loves him some private Christian schools, too.
The idea of redirecting tax dollars to private schools is particular troublesome in Wisconsin, where public schools are stuck under a cap in state funding.
The pitch captures some of the bizarro world nature of tax credit scholarships. Do you want to support public schools and students? You can take some of your tax dollars and direct them to schools. Or--stay with me here-- you could just pay taxes. PIFW wants to answer the question, "How can I direct my money to help students and schools?" Gee-- if only there were some sort of system for collecting a contribution from every wage earner in the state and then bundling those contributions up and portioning them out to schools. If only there were a way to do that!
But of course what gives the tax credit system value added over regular old taxation is that tax credit vouchers let you make sure that your tax dollars aren't going to support Those Peoples' Children. Let's hope that Wisconsin's next governor shares the current governor's understanding of how bad the federal voucher program would be for education.
No comments:
Post a Comment