ICYMI: New Year Already Please (12/31)

Well, this was not a vacation that unfolded as we would have hoped, between injury and illness and absent family, but sometimes that's just how it goes, and what we as humans get for pinning hopes on a particular date set for us instead of just making events fit our own timing. Hope your break has been a good one, and whatever it is you do tonight to celebrate the calendar rolling over, may it be fun and rewarding.

Here's a bit of reading from the week.

Meet Three Of The Neighbors Who United To Defend Public Education In Central Bucks School District

From the Bucks County Beacon, a profile of three folks who stood up in Bucks County, God bless 'em, taking on one very rich guy and a bunch of the Moms for Liberty crowd.

Judge blocks parts of Iowa law banning school library book, discussion of LGBTQ+ issues

The court serves a setback to Iowa's book banning Don't Say Gay law.

Ohio’s Republican governor vetoes trans care restriction and sports ban

Governor Mike DeWine takes the radical step of going to talk to parents and families and people who work in the hospitals before making one of his occasional decent human decisions. NBC news on the story.

Tired of Being Tired (Toward a Better 2024)

Here's the thing. Jose Luis Vilson isn't just back to the blogging thing--he's cranking out several posts a week. So go read this one about approaching the new year, and then click on the [subscribe] button, because you should be reading him regularly.

Public Christian schools? Leonard Leo’s allies advance a new cause

Heidi Przybyla at Politico dives deep into the conservative folks working hard to make taxpayer-funded religious public schools a thing, including the same people who brought us the end of Roe v. Wade.

Why Was It So Hard for Nikki Haley to Say ‘Slavery’? History Has the Answer

Joshua Zeitz at Politico uses Haley's boneheaded fumble to remind us of the story of the Lost Cause and the rewriting of Civil War history. Not directly about education, but this is what some folks want schools to teach.

Retired teachers forced to pay thousands

From New Mexico, a reminder that when retired teachers answer the call to come back and help out, they need to make sure they get the paperwork right.

Angry About Your Kid’s After-School Satan Club? Blame Clarence Thomas.

Adam Laats at The New Republic explains why after school Satan Clubs are just the religious liberty crowd getting just what they asked for.

The Long Lineage of Conservative Mother Movements

Adam Laats again, this time being interviewed at WNYC studios about the history of Moms for Liberty style movements. You can listen or read the transcript.

The Post reviewed 1,000 school book challenges. Here’s what we found.

Hannah Natanson at the Washington Post writes up their study of so very many book challenges and finds, among other things, that the majority came from just 11 people.

Right-Wing Activist Chris Rufo Calls for “Siege” of University at UT

The message, as reported by Brant Bingamon at the Daily News, was the usual Rufo riff. But when it came time for Q&A, things didn't go so well for him.

Making it a Job to be Happy

Anne Lutz Fernandez looks at happiness, the new year, and education. A good read to kick off the new year.

Sad news. Among the reporters taking the buyout offer at the Washington Post is education stalwart Valerie Strauss. At her space, the Answer Sheet, Strauss was always a voice of education reason at an otherwise reformster-friendly outfit. She boosted my work more than a few times and was always supportive and a lovely human being. I'm going to miss her work at WaPo.

Finally, this week I did the obligatory prediction piece for Forbes (I have no desire to look back at 2023, which was pretty rough all around). If I turn out to be wrong, we'll just pretend I never wrote my education stories to watch piece at all. 

If you want to have my stuff just conveniently pop up in your email, subscribe to my substack.

Virginia Lee Burton: An Appreciation

I grew up with Mike Mulligan and Mary Anne, and I have lots of company, including my own children. It's a book that encourages the reader to imagine an author as some aged, retiring, nostalgia-soaked children's book author, but Virginia Lee Burton is something else entirely. Today, I'm setting aside the usual eduranting to look at this extraordinary American author.

The author of Mike Mulligan and His Steam Shovel was just thirty years old when it was published, in the midst of a life that was rich and adventurous and even a little unconventional. (For this next section, I depended mainly on Barbara Elleman's brief but illuminating biography of Burton)

Virginia Lee Burton was born in 1909 in Newton Center, Massachusetts. Her father was Alfred Burton, an engineer who was the first dean at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. A widower with two sons from his first marriage (one ended up as a Supreme Court Justice, the other an architect), Alfred met the eccentric young Lena Yates on a walking trip in France; they soon married, though she was about 22 years younger. They had three children. In the late teens, citing health issues, Lena took the children to California, ending up in the bohemian art scene of Carmel-by-the-Sea.

After Alred retired from MIT in 1921, he joined the family out West, but in 1925 Lena ran off with Carl Cherry, a man 24 years her junior (and the eventual inventor of the Cherry rivet, leading to the founding of Cherry Aerospace, still kicking today). Virginia was 16; she involved herself in arts, especially dance. In 1928 she was prepared to follow her sister back East and even had a contract with a dance troupe when her father broke his leg. She went to take care of him instead, and her dancing career evaporated. 

In 1930, she took work as an illustrator for a newspaper, eventually signing up for a class with George Demetrios, a teacher of drawing and sculpture at the Boston Museum School. In 1931, she and Demetrios married. After a couple of years, the ended up in a small, turn-of-the-century home in Folly Cove, Gloucester, Mass. 

Burton's first attempt at a children's book was, she said, disastrous. But she learned an important lesson, and ever after she fine tuned her stories by telling them over and over to her own children; the parts where children's attention lagged were targeted for rewrites and tweaking.

Burton did illustrations for other peoples' work, but her signature works are her own. Burton was not so much an illustrator as a designer, working text and layout and art all together. Folly Cove itself became a vibrant center of art and design, energized constantly with music and dance and parties and gatherings and Burton's own work as a teacher of design. 

Burton's body of work is actually not that large. She illustrated (and in a couple of cases adapted) six books, and created seven works of her own. You probably already know a couple--you should know them all.

Written for her son Aris, Choo Choo (1937) tells the story of a little engine who runs away, then gets lost and stranded in a dark wood until her crew find her and bring her home. It is rough and chunky in the illustrations. 

That was followed by Mike Mulligan (1939), written for son Mike. She worked on it for a couple of years, slowly developing and tweaking the story, including the final plot solution offered by a young man at a friend's house. A steam shovel that is outdated finds one last big job.

Calico the Wonder Horse (1941) was conceived as a sort of comics format, but it's graphically very cool. It's a western adventure, with Calico up against some Bad Guys in an adventure that comes down to Christmas Eve.

The Little House (1942) won a Caldecott medal. It was based on their own home. Adapted as a Disney short, but you can skip that. The house starts in the country, and the city grows up around it.

Katy and the Big Snow (1943) is about a snowplough that must rescue the city of Geopolis (based on Gloucester) from a tremendous snow storm.

Maybelle the Cable Car (1952) reflects Burton's school days in San Francisco, and tells the story of the movement to rescue that cable cars of that city when they were threatened with replacement by modern buses.

Life Story (1962) is in many ways Burton's magnum opus. She spent eight years on it, and it tells nothing less than the history of the world, from the Big Bang through life in her country home, all presented as if a stage play. It challenges any sort of categorization. 

There are certain threads that run through the works (beyond the attention to graphic design). Curiously, in all books, human beings are secondary characters. And there is an obvious thread of constructs, like Mary Anne and Maybelle and the Little House, that are threatened with being left behind in a world racing forward into modernity. As Elleman does, I see these not as a romanticizing of the past, but as stories of adaption. Stuff happens, and you find a way to move forward; it's certainly not hard to hear that as an echo of Burton's own childhood and youth in which, faced with challenging events, she kept moving forward without bitterness or anger.

There is a gentleness in her stories. In the end, everyone is okay. Choo Choo decides that her work is not so bad. Stewy Stinker and his Bad Men decide to join in the Christmas celebration. Big Bill the bus decides to be a friend, not a rival, to Maybelle. And of course Henry B. Swap finally smiles in a way that is not so mean. 

When I read these books to the board of directors, I'm struck by one other theme which I think particular fits Burton's own life. It's not about past versus future, city versus country. It's about finding the place where you fit and making it your own. Burton and her family made Folly Cove their own, where they were able to pursue their passions and sing and dance and live the lives they wanted to, and in doing so, made it the center of a larger community as well as the foundation of a whole group of artists and designers. There were classes. There was food. There was a giant slab of an outdoor table, made of slightly irregular quarry stone, that could be a picnic table or a dance floor.

Every one of her characters does this, comes down in the place just right by being willing to move forward to become what they can be. Life Story may seem like it's hunting bigger game, but in the final pages it brings the focus from the entire existence of the world to the passing of the seasons and life in a small house in Gloucester. And here are the last two pages:

And now it is dawn--dawn of a new day, a day in spring. Minute by minute the light brightens in the east, turning from cold gray to deep blue to delicate pink. The birds are singing gaily as they await the return of the sun. Down in the green meadow there is a new baby lamb. Now I leave you and turn the story over to you. Look out of your window and in a few seconds you will see the sun rise.

And now it is your Life Story and it is you who play the leading role. The stage is set, the time is now, and the place wherever you are. Each passing second is a new link in the endless chain of Time. The drama of life is a continuous story--ever new, ever changing, and ever wondrous to behold.

You lose a little without her perfect design, but you get the idea. She has spent seventy-six pages rendering the vast spread of history and the world, and you have a place in that vast picture, you, right here, in this moment. 

Burton had worked forever on a book about design that she never finished. Her last years were dominated by her cancer. She passed away in October of 1968. Her husband created a sculpture to her memory, dancing, smiling, kicking joyfully at the sky. 

Like the best of those who create works for "children" she had made some big statements about life, about art. I'll read through the stack again in a few days and raise a glass to her in the new year when Mike Mulligan and Mary Anne celebrate their 85th birthday. 

Moms Launch Another Anti-Woke Group: Awake Americans

Moms for Liberty, which has done a fine job of networking anti-public school culture panic folks across the nation, has had some trouble with the brand in the last few months, what with misbehaving local leaders and reduced election prowess and founding guardians or morality failing to practice what they preach. 

So it's not surprising to find a few Moms looking to move their reactionary eggs to new baskets. One such operation is taking place in the Midwest. An Illinois-based group that has been around for a couple of years is trying to take its anti-woke massage national.

Which group is that?

Awake Illinois launched in May of 2021 and started forming chapters by counties in Illinois. They even had a cool launch video and a sort of slogan ("They can't cancel us"). The video hist the standard points-- schools didn't reopen fast enough, government is overreaching and oppressing businesses, schools are indoctrinating instead of educating. Amid the montage of stock footage is a shot of people celebrating as they cast away their masks. Who are they? "We are regular pro-human citizens." They make it a point to indicate they value humor ("Last year was gnarly" says the video at one point). Perhaps they noticed the general off-putting grimness of the M4L "joyful warriors." They want to defend education against critical race theory. All of this over the Glee cover version of David Bowie's "Heroes."

By February of 2022, they claimed 30,000 members over 32 counties. Their timeline also highlights fighting with the state union and the Tom DeVore-led lawsuits against the state over masking (DeVore was an attorney from American Freedom Society who, after a failed attempt to run for state Attorney General ran into legal troubles of his own). The timeline also notes the election of Glen Youngkin as governor of Virginia, one more reminder that some folks believed that Youngkin's election signaled a special political moment for the rights of (certain) parents. The site also touts Awake Illinois as bi-partisan, which only appears to be true if one considers right-wing and very right-wing as two flavors of partisans.

Who launched this venture?

Awake Illinois's founding president was Shannon Adcock. Adcock graduated from the University of Illinois in 2002 with a degree in BA in Communications, because a comms background seems to be the standard requirement for these groups. Adcock moved to Phoenix for a bit, did some sales and marketing work before starting her own photography studio, returning Naperville, Illinois in 2015. She's married with three kids, who attend a private Christian school. 

Adcock ran for a school board seat in March of 2021, and failed (the official Awake Illinois timeline starts with that election, noting a 12% voter turnout). From Chicago Tribune coverage of a petition calling for Candidate Adcock to step down:

Obed-Horton said she emailed Indian Prairie District 204 school board candidate Shannon Adcock in mid-March regarding the candidate’s objections to culturally responsive teaching and its intent to address implicit bias, racism, privilege and more in public schools. Adcock’s reply included a suggestion that Obed-Horton and other parents open a charter school with culturally responsive teaching in place, she said. In her Change.org petition, she said the email reply was “filled with racist rhetoric.”

Within a month the paperwork for Awake Illinois was under way. 

Awake Illinois quickly garnered a reputation for pivoting from anti-masking to anti-LGBTQ. They were "first and loudest voices" to oppose a family-friendly drag brunch and Drag Queen Bingo for teens. The latter event generated enough threats to result in a cancellation that AwakeIl celebrated on line. Then there was the time Adcock and crew managed to shut down a library.

Adcock became the chair of the DuPage chapter of Moms for Liberty. She went to a school board training session held by the Leadership Institute, the program that would have been run by Moms for Liberty co-founder Bridget Ziegler. A few days later, she announced another attempt at running for school board. Adcock has made a variety of appearances on right-wing media appearances on right-wing media. And she put up her own posts, like "The Perversion of K-12 Education," in which she proudly quotes Corey DeAngelis and argues about the evils of CRT and DEI. 

Adcock was also the center of controversy in 2022 when folks caught wind that she might be appointed to Naperville's Special Events and Cultural Amenities Commission. Once again a petition was launched. 

That appointment might have been a possibility because of Josh McBroom, the original vice-president of Awake Illinois. McBroom left the group to make a successful bid for a Naperville City Council seat. McBroom wasn't with the group long, but he had his moments, like the time he cosigned a demand that U.S. Congressman Sean Casten stop asking his opponent Keith Pekau to disavow Awake Illinois and the award they gave him for being an anti-mask, anti-vax guy. 

McBroom had previously gotten in trouble while serving on the Naperville Park Board Commission for making fun of pro-mask commissioners on social media. And he apparently wants to be a DeSantis delegate to the convention. McBroom's wife is an actual teacher. Once elected, McBroom seems to have vanished his AwakeIl leadership from his bio. 

Awake made many attempts to dabble in politics, like suckering Paul Vallas to appear on a panel while running for Chicago mayor. Only later did Vallas (never a big homework guy) discover that, among other things, AwakeIl had called Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker a groomer. But other GOP candidates signed on to the group's agenda.

Other members of the team.

McBroom was replaced by Helen Levinson, Levinson was the chair of the Cook County chapter of Moms For Liberty and at the center of battling lawsuits over racism in Skokie County schools, in which Levinson's legal team included Stephen Miller's America First Legal firm. Levinson is a sales, marketing and comms professional. 

Steve Lucie joined the leadership board in September 2021. Lucie had been a board candidate recommended by the Illinois Policy Institute until they were directed to some of his tweets on the subject of pandemic responses. In response to a post saying that the Biden administration might impose requirements to get vaccinated, Lucie tweeted "Fuck around and find out assholes!" followed by nine axes. Also, "People that choose not to be 'vaxed' will be the ones getting receipts. The vaxed will pay. Many I see with their own case numbers rising. They may even feel more pain if they continue to threaten the un vaxed." There's more in that vein. 

Lucie helped start "We Stand for Our Students" at the end of his 17-year school board career. The group drew some press, and Awale Illinois were fans. 

In May of 2021, parent John Blakey spoke before a school board about the dangers of CRT:

Watch how our teenagers interact around the neighborhoods and homes; they don't need to be split into identity groups based on skin color nor do they need to be taught how to be an anti-racist, about implicit bias, white supremacy, white privilege, etc. This will only create division.

By August, Blakey was the Director of Equality and Civil Rights for Awale Illinois, regularly speaking out against the Naperville district's equity plan.

In August, the group also signed on Dan Vosnos, who also turns up as a concerned parents, but who is also a well-connected activist and leader of One Chance Illinois-Action (joined up in 2022)-- a group connected to 50CAN (Derrell Bradford serves on its board of directors).

Expanding the brand

Awake Illinois has been busy in 2023, despite the occasional setback like the cancellation of an event about reforming sex ed, due to threats of violence.

Folks in the region have been tracking developments. Including the registration of domains for Awakes in Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Virginia, and Florida. Those domains are "parked" except for Awake Wisconsin, which has the organizations web template in place and is "launching soon" as "a nonpartisan, issue-based grassroots advocacy movement that is partnered with national organizations such as Moms for Liberty and Courage Is A Habit."

But the real development has been the step of going national at Awake Americans. 

Awake Americans is Awake Illinois. They have the same address--2020 Calamos Ct., Suite 200, Naperville, IL 60563, which is actually a "virtual address." The building holds an investment company and also Alliance Virtual Offices, that offered (apparently they're not taking new customers) virtual office space for Naperville professionals, because a "prestigious company solidifies your reputation."

Awake Americans also has exactly the same "parents and patriots" board of directors as Awake Illinois, plus one more. Adcock, Lucie and Levinson are joined by Scarlett Johnson. Johnson is the Moms for Liberty chair for Ozaukee County in Wisconsin, and presumably the head to Awake Wi. Johnson seems particularly agitated about LGBTQ stuff (you can see her protesting with a Proud Boy here).

Awake Americans officially announced their launch in April.  They joined the Naperville Chamber of Commerce in May, raising a few eyebrows. They grabbed their domain in August of 2023 (Thanks to John Norcross and others who tracked this info down), but they had a "launch event" back in June at the Hotel Arista in Naperville. They hosted three speakers:

Noelle Mering, from the Ethics and Public Policy Center, a thinky tank and advocacy group devoted to making Judeo-Christian moral tradition influential in policy discussions. Rick Santorum was once a fellow there. 

Xi Van Fleet, a Virginia mom who left Mao's China and regularly compares critical race theory to the cultural revolution. She's done Hannity, and the far right Independent Women's Forum (the group that started as Women for Clarence Thomas) is a fan. She's popular on the "this is Marxism" circuit.

And James Lindsay, another anti-woke crusader who made "Okay, groomer" a thing. This infamous shitposter is allegedly on the Moms for Liberty advisory board these days.

One outcome if that gathering is a Woke 101 "webinar" to answer the question "Is Marxism in America?" They also offer a "Declaration of Independence from Woke." 

When in the course of human events, it becomes necessary for everyday people to distance themselves from anti-Americanism or Woke sentiment which purveys current culture and policy, and to assume we have awakened to said reality, we reaffirm and "hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among there are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. 

I, therefore, as a citizen of the United States of America, earnestly publish and declare, that I am absolved from any Allegiance to Woke, Marxism, Communism, and/or Anti-Americanism, and that any attempt by the latter to coerce me shall be respectfully rejected.

Awake America proudly says it helped sponsor last July's Family Leadership Summit in Iowa, a big-time political gathering of evangelicals.

And Adcock is no longer listed as the chapter leader for DuPage County Moms for Liberty. Levinson is no longer listed as Cook County chair for M4L. Neither chapter has a Facebook page. Johnson is still listed as the Ozaukee County chapter chair (and legislation chair). 

It's not clear yet what the future holds for this Not-Woke-But-Awake crew. They don't appear to have a lot of political juice just yet. They're over-invested in last year's conservative scary word "woke." And beyond people who watch this kind of stuff carefully, they haven't attracted a lot of attention. They have Facebook and Twitter accounts, both of which are rather sleepy. 

But they have leaders who already have all the Moms for Liberty training and connections, making them perfectly positioned to be a welcoming dinghy for M4L members who want to jump ship. This is a group poised to do some rebranding for the anti-woke, anti-LGBTQ, anti-all-sorts-of-stuff crowd for whom M4L no longer works. We'll see how they do. 

 

Christmas Music

For those who celebrate, may this be a lovely day. For those who don't celebrate, may this be a lovely day. Here's the annually updated list of music for the day that is probably not the stuff you've gotten sick of.

ICYMI: Christmas Eve Edition (12/24)

Later today I'll see my grandchildren, some of whom have flown in from the Left Coast. The Board of Directors, upping their game from previous Christmases, have bounded out of bed early every day this week. And not only are stockings not hung, but unwrapped presents are stashed in various corners of the house and car. At the same time, this is an odd holiday for my family; sad for some reasons and joyous for others. However you meet the season, here's hoping that it's a good one for you.

And yes, I still have some stuff for you to read, if you have a spare minute.

Newly Surfaced Video Of Moms For Liberty Advisor Reveals Religious Extremist Agenda

Jennifer Cohn at the Bucks County Beacon has been doing some tremendous job tracking both the Moms and the christianist right. This piece does some tremendous dot connecting.

What Kind of Bubble is AI?

Cory Doctorow considers the future of AI. "AI is a bubble, and it’s full of fraud, but that doesn’t automatically mean there’ll be nothing of value left behind when the bubble bursts."

The Community Schools Movement Is Running Headlong Into Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’s Hard-Right Agenda

What happens when schools designed to meet the needs of communities and families run into the DeSantis agenda? Jeff Bryant has the story.

Utah charter schools want student data from school districts — so they can advertise to families

Yes, competition is swell, but charter fans would like to give their schools some extra tools to help them "compete."

Fighting Book Bans in Kentucky Schools—and Beyond

At The Nation, Ramona Pierce looks at how reading repression is playing out in Kentucky, where students and the community are fighting back.

Harvard student goes viral for takedown of Moms for Liberty co-founder in Florida

I loathe headlines with "takedown" in them, but this piece highlights Zander Moricz. You may remember him from his graduation speech in which, forbidden to mention gay students, he talked about those with "curly hair" instead. He went back to Sarasota (he's a student at Harvard now) to take Bridget Ziegler to task for condemning publicly what she herself does privately. It is a great speech.

Federal judge rules school board districts illegal in Georgia school system, calls for new map

Gerrymandered school remain a popular segregation tool. A federal judge has told Georgia to shape up. Jeff Amy reports for the AP.

About the “Bizarre Coalition” Weighing Standardized Testing “Big Changes,” and More.

The indispensable Mercedes Schneider takes a look at the strange coalition that has come up to fic high stakes testing, and how it compares to some bizarre coalitions of the past.

Someone complained about a book in a Great Barrington classroom. Then the police showed up

Once again, this time in Massachusetts, somebody decided to call the law to go into a school to look for a naughty book. Quite a surprise to the English teacher who was still in the classroom when the cop showed up.

A peek into the experience of a student journalist at New College

Chloe Rusek is a journalism student at New College, the one that Ron DeSantis is trying to turn into a conservative powerhouse. This is her story of trying to interview university president Richard Corcoran. And trying and trying. 

Why Youngstown State matters more than Harvard

Will Bunch at the Philadelphia Inquirer says that what's happening is not as important as what's happening at the many public universities where most students attend. And what's happening is a version of The New College--party hacks are being put in charge.

Panic! Pandemic Learning Loss!

Thomas Ultican reads the latest chicken littling from The 74 and says, "Hey, wait a minute." And he has data.

A Crowded Table

Nancy Flanagan offers a holiday reflection. 

Dominionism for Dummies

If you've been hearing the term Dominionism and keep wondering, "Well, what is that, anyway?" this post is for you (if you already know, you can correct me in the comments).

The conservative world of Christianity is not one homogenous blob, but a continuum. Along that continuum you can find folks who believe that a public official's moral and values matter and folks who believe that Christians make better leaders that non-Christians. But way out beyond them, you'll find the Dominionists, who believe that Christians (their kind of Real True Christians) should rule the country.

Watch for references to the Seven Mountains. These "mountains" are religion, family, education, government, media, arts & entertainment, and business, and Dominionists believe that their brand of Christian should rule all of them. The Seven Mountain Mandate showed up in the 1970s; here's the origin story from Elle Hardy in The Outline 

The Seven Mountain Mandate came into being in 1975, when God allegedly delivered a concurrent message to missionary movement leader Loren Cunningham, Campus Campus Crusade for Christ founder Bill Bright, and televangelist Francis Schaeffer to invade the “seven spheres.” The largely dormant idea was resurrected in 2000, when Cunningham met with “strategist, futurist and compelling communicator” Lance Wallnau, and told him about the vision of 25 years earlier. The “prophetic” Wallnau, a 63-year-old business consultant based in Dallas, with a “Doctorate in Ministry with a specialization in Marketplace” from Phoenix University of Theology immediately saw the idea’s potential and began promoting seminars and training courses on the theory as a “template for warfare” for the new century. Its real surge in popularity began in 2013, when Wallnau co-authored the movement’s call to arms, Invading Babylon: The 7 Mountain Mandate, with Pastor Bill Johnson from the prominent California megachurch Bethel Church.

I added some links and emphasis there. Lance Wallnau is one of the names to watch for.

These are not your father's evangelicals. Back in the days of the Moral Majority, it was enough to try to bring people to Christ or thwart abortions or pray away some gays. Dominionists want to remake the country in their image.

Dominionists and Christian Nationalists are not exactly the same thing, but the Christian Nationalists serve an important function in the Dominionist argument. Fake historians like the beloved David Barton make the argument that the framers absolutely intended to set up a theocratic Christian nation, and that Godless secularists have derailed their God-given intentions. The United States, they argue, was set up specifically to have Christians take dominion over.

There's a subtler version of this as well. When, for instance, christianists argue that secularism is not an absence of religion, but a form of religion itself, which serves as a way of quietly resetting the argument to say, "Look, the country is already a theocracy. All that's left to argue is which God should be in charge."

New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) is another term to look for. These are Dominionists as well, led by guys like Dutch Sheets and Jim Garlow, who are well-connected in the political world to a multitude of figures, including new House Speaker Mike Johnson. Jenifer Cohn has covered all of this at great length; here's her quick background on NAR:

The NAR was named and organized by the late C. Peter Wagner, who wrote in 2007 that the seven mountains had “become a permanent fixture in my personal teaching on taking dominion,” adding that “our theological bedrock is what has been known as Dominion Theology.” He explained that, “Dominion has to do with control. Dominion has to do with rulership. Dominion has to do with authority and subduing. And it relates to society. In other words, what the values are in Heaven need to be made manifest here on earth. Dominion means being the head and not the tail. Dominion means ruling as kings … So we are kings for dominion.”

If this all seems very non-democratic, well, yeah. As Katherine Stewart points out in her book The Power Worshippers, the idea is that "legitimate government rests not on the consent of the governed but adherence to the doctrines of a specific religious, ethnic, and cultural heritage."

That authoritarian bent is why Domionionism can get along so well with Donald Trump. He may not be very Christian, but he is certainly amenable to sweeping away all the Others that Dominionists see as an obstacle to taking their rightful dominion over the nation. And Dominionists like Paula White, the Trump "spiritual advisor," stay close. 

Dominionism has been on the fringes so long that it has become adept at sliding by under the surface of other movements. Cohn has just laid out the ties of Moms For Liberty to the movement. The move to commandeer school boards often has a Dominionist flavor. 

This is a deep and twisty rabbit hole, and it prompts one to repeatedly ask, "They can't really be serious about this, can they?" Watch enough video and you realize they are. Realize too that these are not crazy-pants mouth-frothing obviously-out-there folks. The man in this mountain-buying couple is a guy I graduated from high school, as regular a guy as you'll ever meet. Good Rotarian. Nice person. 

It should go without saying that not all of us of the Christian faith want to take dominion over every aspect of the country. There are plenty of conservative Christians who don't dream of "taking back" all seven mountains and turning this into a nation where all are required to bow before God.

But Dominionists are out there. They are not interested in democracy or compromise (you don't make deals with Satan and his demons), and in the most extreme cases, they are willing to do whatever it takes to get power.

If you'd like to know more, read Stewart's book (written in 2019, and about to become the basis of a documentary by Rob Reiner). A new book by Tim Alberta, The Kingdon, the Power and the Glory, is also useful.

On the dead bird app, follow @KiraResistance, @jennycohn1, and @mentack, at least for starters. 

These folks absolutely want to replace the current public education system with one focused on their particular concept of God and faith; whether that system is private or public is immaterial. Either way they'd like it financed by taxpayers. When they talk about religious freedom, what they mean is the freedom for their conception of religion to dominate the system to the exclusion of all others (aka "the wrong ones"). Their goals are incompatible with a democratic pluralistic society, and with God’s help, and to His glory, and for their own power, they intend to come out on top. 

OK: Ed Secretary Ryan Walters' Terrible Horrible No Good Very Bad Year

To wrap up the year, Education Dudebro Ryan Walters has been subpoenaed by House members of his own party to explain what the hell is going on in the department of education under his leadership.

Once upon a time, Walters was a history teacher, and pretty good at it by many accounts. But his trek to the higher levels of Oklahoma politics has been accompanied by lurch into MAGAville, where he somehow became a chosen buddy of Governor Stitt. That's despite the fact that he mismanaged a bunch of federal relief funds in an attempt to boost vouchers. He tried to make an example out of a school librarian who let students, you know, read books.

Once Walters was elected to the State Superintendent spot, he made it clear that his brand would be culture war baloney; one of his first acts was to take down the Oklahoma Educators Hall of Fame pictures, and when folks protested, he offered a statement:

All the photographs will be sent to the local teachers’ unions. When my administration is over, the unions can use donor money and their lobbyists to take down photographs of students and parents and reinstall the photographs of administrators and bureaucrats.

Walters drew headlines for moves like explaining that Tulsa Race Massacre was not about race. He called the teachers union a "terrorist organization." He also proposed a host of rules for restricting reading, mandatory outing of students, searching out the dread CRT, and backing it all up with threats to take away a district's accreditation if they dared to defy him. In fact, just today followed the Chris Rufo playbook and announced his intent to ban DEI from all schools. 

By February, Rep. Mark McBride of the Education Committee was ready to "put this gentleman in a box" and "focus on public education and not his crazy destruction of public education." 

Things have not improved since. Walters has tried to push school prayers, the proposed religious charter school, and a variety of other hard right christianist supremacy noises. 

But while Walters' ideological activism may draw the headlines, there also seems to be a problem with basic competence in the job. 

Employees have been fleeing the department--80 gone by September. In May, one departed whistleblower said that Walters office had simply failed to follow through on millions of dollars in federal grant money. Terri Grissom estimated between $35 and $40 million hasn't been given to districts to spend, and uncounted other millions hadn't been applied for at all. And Grissom says that Walters simply lied to legislators about the state of grants. This fall, districts have discovered that Walters' office has somehow gummed up the works so badly that millions in federal grants are not getting to the schools where they could do some good. 

Another resignation came from Pamela Smith-Gordon, a handpicked Walters ally who left out of frustration with the lack of leadership. She sent an angry letter that said in part:

While desperately wanting to support you, the lack of leadership and availability within our own OSDE is impossible to ignore. If your physical presence is not required for leadership, then the question arises as to why the position exists with a salary attached to it. 

The lack of Walters physical presence in the office has been a recurring theme. Reported Rep. Jacob Rosencrans

We’re hearing from folks that are looking in and they're all saying the same thing. Ryan Walters isn’t there. I talked to someone who is a constituent of mine who said that he is not a mean guy. He is always there with a handshake and a smile, but he is never there, literally.

In response to Smith-Gordon's departure, McBride (who is an actual Republican) said, “I really don’t know what’s going on over there. Nobody does. There is some lack of transparency.”

Walters' department, which regularly cranks out Trump-style PR about how Walters is "driving change in education for Oklahoma students like never before" doesn't just stonewall the legislature--they thumb their nose at it. When McBride made a second request for certain basic information from the department, Walters' top advisor Matt Langston sent a note--which someone slipped under McBride's office doors--saying "Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me." (Fun fact: Langston allegedly lives in Texas.) In another response was a letter from Langston, on OSDE letterhead, calling McBride a "whiny Democrat."

In response to this petty dickishness, House Demnocrat Mickey Dollens proposed the "Do Your Job Act" aimed directly at Walters and his department. Well, he's a Democrat, and angry at that.

But McBride and House Speaker Charles McCall and Rep. Rhonda Baker are GOP, and they signed off on the subpoena to get Walters to show up and answer some questions, including details --but not to the legislature. In interviews, McBride just sounds tired and frustrated.

“If there's nothing there, show me,” said Rep. Mark McBride, ( R) House Education Budget and Appropriations Chair. “There's no ‘I gotcha' question’ here. It's just questions about public education that any appropriator would ask.”

McBride says he tried to work with Walters and his chief policy advisor Matt Langston, but after many requests for basic information were left unmet, he says he had no other option but to issue the subpoena.

And McBride's more formal statements don't seem aimed at grinding axes.

As Chairman of the Appropriations and Budget Education Subcommittee, I am constitutionally bound to ask questions and statutorily entitled to have them answered of the leadership of the legislatively appropriated OSDE. As those questions have not been answered, and no voluntary answer is forthcoming, I have exercised my power as chairman to subpoena the superintendent to produce the records and communications requested by the committee. Where taxpayer money is concerned we must be diligent. The time for playing political games is over, and the time for answers is at hand.

Walters' office has responded with its usual grace. Langston has called McBride a liar. And after initially not responding to the subpoena, Walters decided to give an "exclusive" to Fix affiliate Fox23, in which he said stuff like this:

It's disappointing to see some folks in my own party decided to sell their souls for 30 pieces of silver from the teachers union, but I'm never going to stop or back down. I'm going to keep fighting for the parents of Oklahoma [and] the tax payers of Oklahoma. Your kids are too important. The future of this state is too important,

He also claims that his has been the "most transparent" administration. And he touts his "town halls," some of which have been pretty contentious. And while Walters has often pointed to his meetings with superintendents around the state as a sign of his outreach and transparency, a survey of superintendents found that 150 of the 190 who responded had met with him exactly zero minutes. A touted Zoom meeting was about 15 minutes long, superintendents were not allowed to speak, and no questions were answered. They reported a "continued silence." And they report that Walters' culture war concerns do not reflect the day to day issues they actually deal with in the real world.  From an NPR story:

Matt Riggs is the superintendent of the small, rural district of Macomb. He said Walters’ portrayal of schools is like a “caricature… so far outside of what is real.”

“What he has done through his entire approach to public life, from what I’ve seen, is create dragons for himself to slay,” Riggs said. “Do we have students here that, you know, some may identify in different ways? I’m sure we do. But our charge is to try to make those students’ lives better. Our charge is not to make them part of some kind of political conversation.”

Riggs said those dragons — leftist indoctrination, pornography pushing, terrorist teachers’ unions — just don’t exist. In a high-poverty area like Macomb, there are real problems, but Riggs says he doesn’t see a point in bringing those issues to Walters.

But the legislature sees a point in bringing Walters to address those issues. He might even have to explain his desire to slay his imaginary dragons instead of getting school districts the support they need and that their taxpayers deserve. 

In the end, the worst thing about Walters may not be his Trumpian bombast, his thirst for media attention, his obsession with culture wars, or his ideological certainty that he need answer to nobody. The worst thing about Walters may be that he won't actually do the job for which he campaigned so hard. Is incompetence worse than intolerance? I'm not sure even a legislative hearing can determine that one, but Walters is both, and that's bad news for the children of Oklahoma.

Walters has till January 5 to answer the subpoena. Mark your calendar.