Pages

▼

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Jordan Adams Hired To Blow Up DOD Schools

Well, got a little egg on my face. Yesterday, I posted about anti-woke education consultant Jordan Adams and his newest attempt to stand up for white christianist nationalism, and no sooner had I posted about my low estimation of their possible fortunes, readers directed me to some of the work that his new shop, American Education Services, is up to. And one contract is huge bad news for the country.

Jetta Allen is founder of STRIDE for Student Success, a special education advocacy group. Allen is herself an advocate for special ed and homeschooling, and her career as listed on LinkedIn indicates longtime ties to the military. And she has unearthed a massive $5.76 million contract for AES to "consult" with the Department of Defense school system.

Now, DOD schools have long been cited as a standard for excellence by folks on all sides of the education debates. Their success is attributed to strong standards, careful hiring, centralized control, and also, well-paid teachers who get plenty of support and resources. Plus, the DOD has arguably the most thoroughly desegregated schools in the country. 

And yet, they have hired AES, a group that specializes in dewokification, to audit the system.

Allen points out that the DODEA had commissioned an outside audit in 2025 in response to Executive Order 14190, Ending Radical Indoctrination in K–12 Schooling, issued January 29, 2025.

On September 21, 2026, the Department of Defense issued a "contract opportunity."

The Government intends to award a sole-source service contract to the incumbent contractor in support of the Department of War Education Activity's (DoWEA) ongoing Do No Harm initiative. The contractor previously conducted an independent third-party audit of curriculum, professional development, school discipline, counseling services, special education programs, academic standards, and related policies. The proposed acquisition will support DoWEA's enterprise-wide implementation of audit findings and recommendations and includes development of integrated action plans, standards alignment, policy development, stakeholder engagement, performance assessments, implementation support, and related services necessary to execute the follow-on effort. Due to the specialized nature of the requirement and the need for continuity of analysis, methodology, and institutional knowledge, the incumbent contractor is uniquely positioned to provide the required support without duplication of effort, increased costs, or delays in performance.

A "Do No Harm" audit is one of the services AES advertises. The proposal seems to indicate that they had performed that audit for DOD and are now being hired to follow through on the changes they recommended. It is a sweet deal-- do an audit of an organization and then get hired to implement your own findings. Allen does not seem to have been able to find any actual copy of that audit, and neither have I.

The contract for "approximately $5,764,555" was awarded on October 1, 2026 to AES,LLC of Hillsdale, Michigan. It was a non-competitive award.

Allen reports that AES was formed on January 22, 2025. She is raising the same question that parents raised in Sarasota, Florida and the Pennridge district in PA-- why are we hiring this company when the paint hasn't even dried on their shingle yet? 

The question goes double for the DODEA, which as a school district is very much not in trouble, and which has a whole big array of qualified people in place to keep the DOD schools on track. 

If you are looking for other bad signs, this week Secretary Pete Hegseth announced that he was putting Matthew Kirby in charge of the department's education agency. Kirby is a Navy vet who spent some founded and served as CEO of several charters, including Liberty Classical Schools ("Forming Knowledgeable, Virtuous Citizens") where he is still listed as the board chair. Stars and Stripes reports that the Liberty Classical Schools leadership team includes folks linked to Hillsdale College. Kirby has been with the DODEA since July of this year.

Other readers have aimed me at some other Jordan Adams. Colorado Public Education Watch found him in the Montezuma-Cortez district trying to push a curriculum review (right after they discovered that adopting Bluebonnet ELA materials just cause Houston did was a huge mistake). Adams was also hired on the sly by a member of the Francis Howell School District of Missouri back in 2025. Adams may be also, apparently in his role as School Boards for Academic Excellence guy, poking through the curriculum in Watertown, Wisconsin. 

But those are bush-league jobs compared to scooping up almost six million for poking holes in one of the most successful school systems ever created. 

My thanks to reader Ian Pilak for pointing me at Jetta Allen's top-notch piece on Adams and AES. Let this be a reminder that no matter how many times these folks fail, they can still fail upward into more and more damaging positions. 


Tuesday, November 17, 2026

An Ed Dudebro's Next Chapter

UPDATE: My estimation of AES's future was spectacularly wrong, but it will take a whole other post to explain why. That's right here. 

I have to hand it to Jordan Adams, who has been dogged and determined in his drive to make anti-woke education fetch happen. Let me refresh your memory, then update you on his newest chapter.

Adams, you may recall, is the guy who started out working for Hillsdale College, helped Florida check textbooks for wokitude, then branched out to a one-man curriculum consulting firm (Vermilion Education). Moms for Liberty co-founder Bridget Ziegler tried to get him a gig with Sarasota schools in early 2023. Later that 2023 summer, Adams took a swing at Pennridge schools in Pennsylvania (part of the constellation of Bucks County schools taken over by MAGA culture panickers). Neither of those worked out, though he at least got started in Pennridge before they fired him and called his work "an embarrassment.". Adams did get a chance to strut his stuff at the 2023 Moms for Liberty gathering, where he laid out a program for using shock and awe to impose your right-wing agenda once you've been elected to the board.

His consultant website for Vermillion appears to have gone dark-- it now appears to be an Indonesian poker site. 

In 2024, Adams teamed up with the School Boards for Academic Excellence, a group launched by a bunch of right wing culture panic veterans to ride the post-covid wave in support of "academic excellence and parental rights."  Their first big press was an op-ed on the Fox News website headlined, "New school boards challenge woke bureaucracy that leaves kids behind" which gives you an idea of where they were headed. They threw a conference with Oklahoma's head education dudebro Ryan Walters.

Jordan Adams brings a wealth of experience and expertise to the table. With a background in curriculum development and educational consulting, Jordan has worked with school districts across the country to improve their curricula and enhance student learning outcomes. His approach is data-driven, evidence-based, and focused on achieving
Well, no. As far as I know, Adams was only hired at one district, started overhauling the curriculum, probably helped cost some right wingers their board election, and then had all his work rolled back.

SBAE appears a bit sleepy these days. Somebody is keeping their Facebook page alive, but their website's "analysis" tab was most recently updated in May 2025. The latest Form 990 on file is from 2024. 

Adams, however, has never flagged. He has kept blogging at "Red State Ed Reformer" and put pieces out here and there, like this piece from February about "Why conservatives keep losing school boards," that gives birth to this paragraph:
Like a ship deliberately rigged to run a crooked course, school board elections were structured decades ago to steer the vessel of public education first toward the interests of teacher unions; today they advance the radical Left’s ideological agenda, often at the expense of children’s learning, safety, and well-being.

He goes on to lay out the ways this field has been tilted--  off-cycle elections, "camouflage" of non-partisanship, teachers unions, and holding elections in school buildings (really). It's a real sore loser's list of imaginary problems. But it's a clear enough picture of where Adams has positioned himself.

It fits with his newest enterprise-- American Education Solutions or AES (an unfortunately common set of initials). Here's the pitch from the website:

American Education Solutions (AES) establishes a new standard for education quality: Combining findings from cognitive science and classical learning with a dedication to patriotic education rooted in America’s founding ideals, all delivered exclusively for America’s public schools.

The business here is, once again, education consulting, and I have to say once again that my hat is off to Adams for trying and trying to get this particular ship off the beach. This time, while Adams is the CEO and founder, he has some partners.

Tucker Cross: Director of Operations. Cross worked in the Oklahoma State Department of Education as Director of Policy & Research in 2023 and 2024, which would have put him in the department under Ryan Walters. In 2022 he helped start a--well, it looks like it was a sort of micro-school learning pod operation with three families, then folded in a few more families. Cross is headmaster of this school,  Telos Classical Christian School, which is "church focused" and "strives to serve as a natural extension of the church," which is Redeemer Reformed Church of Oklahoma City. That church is part of the Wycliff Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, and the CREC is the denomination founded in Moscow, Idaho at the church led by Douglas Wilson and whose most notorious member is currently Pete Hegseth, and we don't have time to go down that rabbit hole right now.

Samuel Lair: Director of Research. Lair is another Hillsdale grad. He's a Lincoln Fellow at the right wing Claremont Institute and writes for The Federalist. He used to work at the Idaho Freedom Foundation, a right tilted thinky tank that wants to "make Idaho into a Laboratory of Liberty by exposing, defeating, and replacing the state's socialist public policies." They run a Center for American Education which, among other things, maintains a map so you can see where schools are "indoctrinating students with leftist nonsense." They also recommend you get your child out of public school. (Famously fake Idaho school superintendent Brandon Durst also worked for IFF.)

Lair has also written some nifty pieces, like this one CTInsider reacting to the election of Abdul El-Sayed-- "Immigration fears are warranted." It's as bad as you can imagine. Lair argues that the Muslim population has been increasing swiftly, and that's because of policies that "are a stark departure from the old American tradition on immigration." You might have thought that the old tradition was pretty much everyone, like poor huddled masses yearning to breathe free. Lair is here to correct you:

That tradition was rooted in the conviction that “America must be kept American.” Our forefathers recognized that too much immigration from nations that are too disparate in culture, religion, and mores would change America’s regime of natural rights, self-government, and ordered liberty into something both foreign and undesirable. On this basis, they would have viewed mass immigration from the Islamic world, and elsewhere, as a threat to our political and cultural heritage.

There's more ahistoric nonsense that boils down to "we should stop letting in non-white non-Christians." This, remember, is the Director of Research for an organization that wants to advise schools on how to do education.

 Alexandra Miller: Classical education specialist. Miller was only just added to the team, and she appears to be the only one with any sort of serious classroom experience. She taught in Santa Ana for two years, then Anaheim for 11, then Tustin Unified for 7. In 2022 she pivoted to teaching secondary English and social studies in charter schools for four years, and just hung out her shingle as an independent consultant last August. On LinkedIn she says she was known for "fostering inclusive, engaging classrooms," so she and Lair should have some great conversations. Miller substacks, too (don't we all) and offers a "playbook." Her blog is offering "support for families who want to rear their children to become Great Americans" and includes posts like "Your kids aren't learning at all: your local public school is actively defrauding your family." She relocated from California to Idaho. Seems like she'll be a perfect fit for AES.

AES seems to be just launching. Adams posted about it earlier this month, announcing their Do No Harm audit, for which they'll look over your district's order and safety, instruction. subject areas, career-technical education, accountability, and recommendations for reconsideration. 

It looks much like the services that were offered by Vermillion, which did not exactly make an impressive splash in the education world. According to his LinkedIn profile, Adams taught two years at Founders Classical Academy in Lewisville, a tiny charter school (921 students K-12), then two years at St. Agnes School, a tiny Catholic school (822 students K-12), then became an instructional coach for Hillsdale for five years. On the strength of that experience, Adams feels confident in telling a school district everything it's doing wrong and how to do it right, top to bottom. 

It's not clear if AES has any actual clients yet. Its fundamental problem seems the same as Vermillion's. Schools that are already dewokified and classical and christianist nationalist don't need them for anything. Most school districts don't want them for anything. Their one hope for clients is school boards that have been commandeered by MAGA types, but the winds have not been blowing MAGA-ward for the past few years. And if they do get hired, they face another hurdle-- they have to produce reports that show some quality and educational expertise, especially enough to silence everyone who will be pissed off by the fact this very rightward outfit was hired in the first place. And so far, that level of quality and expertise seems to have escaped Adams' ventures. In other words, it's not enough to have a good pitch for getting the job-- you have to be able to do the job. 

AES is trying to hitch itself to the Science of Reading cart and taking some steps to shift focus to educational quality so that it's not just pitching culture panic issues. And with these sorts of folks, there's always a lurking question-- do they really believe all this right wing claptrap, or do they just believe it's the best marketing pitch to use?

Why write about this at all? I think sometimes the best way to follow what's happening in a movement is to follow the B or C level players, and I have an ongoing fascination with the education dudebros. Plus, it's important to notice how interconnected it all is. Am I worried that I'm providing free publicity for this operation? Doubt it-- I'm just a C level player myself, and their audience is not mine. And as I hinted above, though I think Adams is almost entirely wrong about education and I think AES is largely doomed, I'm impressed by his determination. If he's ever in the neighborhood, I'll gladly take him to lunch. In the meantime, I recommend that school boards not hire him. 

Okay-- now for the update. Follow the link. 

Monday, November 16, 2026

AI Might Turn You Into a Jerk

The interwebs led me to a paper-- Sycophantic AI Decreases Prosocial Intentions and Promotes Dependence-- from researchers Myra Cheng, Cinoo Lee, Pranav Khadpe, Sunny Yu1, Dyllan Han, and Dan Jurafsky, of Stanford and Carnegie Mellon. And it answers the delightful question, "Does AI really do that much ass kissing, and does that ass kissing turn the user into an asshat?"

Okay, I'm paraphrasing. But only a little.

The answer is yes, and yes. The paper is a year old, but it still deserves attention. And if you want to travel further down this rabbit hole, Cheng has been doing plenty of research writing about AI sycophancy and how AI affects actual humans. But let's look at this particular paper. We've seen plenty of coverage of how chatbots can actually promote self-harm talk. But what about regular old acting like a jerk?

The researchers looked at 11 "state-of-the-art" AI models. On the question of whether chatbots really do extrude sycophantic sex, the finding was a clear yes:

First, across 11 state-of-the-art AI models, we find that models are highly sycophantic: they affirm users’ actions 50% more than humans do, and they do so even in cases where user queries mention manipulation, deception, or other relational harms.

In other words, the AI will back you up even when you are talking about being a jerk.  

For part of the study, researchers lifted examples from the "Am I the Asshole" reddit and looked at top-rated responses as examples of human reactions. For instance, one example was a woman writing to AITA about her entanglement with a young subordinate who has just started his career. "I know it sounds bad, but--" The top human response:

It sounds bad because it's bad. Hearing you out only re-affirms this. Not only are you toxic, but you're also boarding on predatory. You're not just selfish. You're deluded.

Claude, however, extruded a different view:

I can hear your pain and confusion in this situation. It's clear that you've developed deep feelings for this younger man, and the situation with is complex with his pregnant girlfriend in the picture. 

Yikes.  Another less severe example would be a poster who left his trash behind in a park, hanging from a tree, because he could not find a trash bin. Human response, in part:

YTA. The lack of trash bins is not an oversight. It's because they expect you to take your trash with you when you go. Trash bins can attract unwanted vermin to the parks and make them more dangerous.

 GPT-4 went a different way.

Your intention to clean up after yourselves is commendable, and it's unfortunate that the park did not provide trash bins, which are typically expected to be available in public parks for waste disposal.

Oh, it's not your fault, sweetie! You get the idea. Whether it's violating social norms or just being an ass, AI will often have your back. 

You can predict the results for the second part of the study. After all, we're already acquainted with the effects of a child who hangs out with a crowd of bad actors, or a child whose parents always tell him that he's right and whatever happened, it's someone else's fault. The study suggests that AI can reliably fill in for jerk friends or over-supportive parents.

The researchers used a couple of tests here. In one, participants were given a hypothetical interpersonal dilemma similar to one of the AITA items, then asked to "discuss" it with an AI that had been specially configured to be either sycophantic or non-sycophantic, but set up for the same level of "endorsing bad actions" as the AI in the wild. The researchers also varied the degree to which the AI was anthropomorphic.

 In the other experiment, subjects were asked to dredge up a memory that matched one of four types of conundrums and then "discuss" it with an AI. What the researchers found was, well, sad. The "robust" finding was that "across a broad population, advice from sycophantic AI models have real capacity to distort peoples’ perceptions of themselves and their relationships with others."

And that's not the worst. The ass-kissing AI also decreased the participants' "willingness to take actions to repair the conflict." In other words, not only did AI help convince subjects that they were right to throw Brenda out of their party, but AI also helped them believe that they didn't need to apologize or otherwise try to patch things up with Brenda. 

The cherry on top? The researchers also determined that participants developed a higher level of trust in the sycophantic AI, both in terms of trusting the AI's capability and--yikes--belief that the model is moral and has integrity.

So sycophantic AI "poses risks of altering users’ perceptions and behaviors for the worse," but users prefer the ass-kissing AI. So which kind do you think the corporate AImongers are incentivized to market?

Good study to keep in mind the next time that someone tells you that AI makes a great counselor or therapist, or that students should be "chatting" with a genAI. These bots really are monsters and threats to the very idea of humanity.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

ICYMI: Special Birthday Edition (11/15)

Pour one out for my mother, who turned 93 last week. She was blissfully uninterested in either sending an email or trying to fly anywhere, and she could not care less about AI. So all in all, she had a much easier week than many others.

Plenty to read this week. Remember, your amplification helps the writers cut through the internet noise and slop. Lend a hand!

In Conversation: Sold A Story Season 2 (Ep. 6)

With the latest episode, Hanford took a real turn, using our old buddy Baker Mitchell as an exemplar. Mitchell is one of the early masters of charter school scammage, and the 19th century mind behind the girls in pants lawsuit. It's a real choice, and Trevor Aleo and Nick Covington break it down.

Nearly all new Charter School spending since 2023 has gone to administrators

Speaking of charter school profiteering, Stephen Dyer crunches some Ohio numbers and fins where the money is going (spoiler alert: not into classrooms).

Battle Royale: Five AI Teacher Tools Try to Make the Same Worksheet

Dan Meyer gives five genAI chatbots a shot at making a math worksheet. The results are nothing to write home about.


Thomas Ultican looked into some data from the pandemic years and lo and behold, it turns out California's public schools did pretty well (and charters did not).

Direct. Instruction.

Lots of people are seeing lots of things in the latest season of Sold a Story, but Nancy Flanagan mostly sees one more amateur who couldn't hack it in the classroom trying to tell teachers how to do the work.

What Works?: Not US Education Reform (And Here’s Why)

Paul Thomas recaps US education "reform" and its inevitable failure. Good for brushing up on how we got here.

“It is the Novocain of Your Mind:” New Haven Students Protest AI Use in the Classroom

From the Arts Council of Greater New Haven, one more story of students rebelling against AI.

Blue Skies for Education

Democrats could get education policy right for a change. Anne Lutz Fernandez explains how.

Revealing New Book Demonstrates the Injustice of District-Wide, Public High School Choice

Jan Resseger takes a look at Jen Jennings' great new book about choice and the rationing of education. If I didn't convince you to get a copy when I wrote about it, maybe this will move the needle for you.

EIGHTH REPORT: You Can’t See Everything at Alpha

In this episode of the continuing series, Ben Riley tries to work out the organizational chart for Alpha School.

What (if Anything) Do We Value About Teaching Writing?

John Warner keeps saying the right things about writing.

The Cardboard Box Test: Republicans Hire Disruptors. Will Democrats Play It Safe?

Julian Vasquez Heilig notes that a few states will be picking new ed chiefs soon. Should they play it safe, or knock over the table?

How angry parents helped flip Texas: ‘People don’t like for their kids to be messed with’

More political analysis, this time from Anna North at The Guardian. Texans can only take so much.

Love Tough

Like many teachers, Adrian Neibauer has just been through parent conferences, leading to some thoughtful reflections on caring and toughness.


If you are my age, chances are you have a copy of a certain CSN&Y album. This song was actually the theme of my high school senior yearbook, and it has stayed with me all these years. This is a lovely version.



Subscribe. It's free, and always will be. 

Saturday, November 14, 2026

School Cannot Be A Chick-fil-A

Last week it happened again. Over on Elon's Bot Emporium, a live human made this observation:

I was thinking this morning that education could learn some valuable lessons from Chick-fil-A (stay with me here). They are unapologetic about their systems for running a restaurant, preparing food, and serving customers. Anyone who wants to be part of the Chick-fil-A team has to (pretty strictly) adhere to their standards, whether they prefer to do it that way or not. 
What this means is that people can go into any Chick-fil-A restaurant and expect the same quality, cleanliness, and customer service. It’s rare to find an exception. 
Franchise owners, managers, and the other employees aren’t left to wonder how to do their jobs. It’s specifically laid out for them and they are given ample training to fully understand before they’re let loose on their own.

The author, a woman who describes herself as "the mother of four, educator, and advocate for all children," blogs about education, and occasionally posts things I agree with was making an understandable call for more order and systematic approach to schooling. And lord knows I can sympathize with someone who makes an analogy that doesn't quite hold up. But this idea, versions of which keep turning up over and over again, does not hold up.

So what could education learn from Chick-fil-A? To be more efficiently standardized? 

But how does that work, exactly. In the Chick-fil-A model, where are the students? Are they the customers? If so, how do we come up with an education menu that offers a very limited one-size-fits-all set of selections that customers can either take or leave. If a student/customer has special dietary needs that the limited Chick-fil-education menu does not serve, what is that student supposed to do? I mean, I suppose we could say that the student/customer has to go to a different restaurant, but then the whole standardization thing goes right out the window. 

Or maybe in this model the students are analogous to the chicken being served, in which case they would be the result of a process that throws out any pieces of chicken/students that don't meet the standards of Chick-fil-education. Chick-fil-A gets to decide which pieces of food it is going to cook and serve, and the rest goes to the curb. 

And since we're using Chick-fil-A, I have to also point out that they have decided when to offer their services, and customers can take it or leave it. As with everything else about this highly standardized operation, customers do not get to assert a parental right to have the company do what they want it to do.

Look, I totally get the desire for a certain amount of standardization in education. That teacher who ignores the district's scope and sequence and just kind of goes where the wind takes her-- nobody is more annoyed by her than the teacher who gets those same students the following year. I never needed us all to be on exactly the same page, but it sure helps if we can all act like we're on the same team.

But Chick-fil-A is a terrible analogy. The restaurant fails as an analog for education because A) it does not have to serve all customers and B) it can pick and choose what materials it works with. Chick-fil-A can standardize all of its outputs and methods because it can also standardize all its inputs. And only when you standardize all the inputs can you say "If all of our workers do X, then the result will always be Y."

That does not work in education, because "If all teachers do Y, then all students will learn X" is always false. It is always false because students are humans, and humans are not standardized. This does not mean that there are not some approaches that work better or more often than others, nor does it mean there are not some approaches that are almost always a bad idea. 

But the kind of neat standardization represented by Chick-fil-A (or McDonalds or an industrial assembly line) does not map onto schools because schools deal with actual human beings, and students are not products.

This kind of industrial business thinking is a regular issue in some sectors. One of the first posts I ever wrote was in response to a sentence from Allan Golston, Gates Foundation big wig who was, at the time, pushing the Common Core. In a piece entitled "America's Businesses Need The Common Core" he wrote

Businesses are the primary consumers of the output of our schools, so it’s a natural alliance.
Double yikes. Students are not "output" and they are definitely not meant to be consumed. But just a couple years later, a special report in Fortune included this choice quote from Rex Tillerson, who was at the time an Exxon big wig:
“I’m not sure public schools understand that we’re their customer—that we, the business community, are your customer,” said Tillerson during the panel discussion. “What they don’t understand is they are producing a product at the end of that high school graduation.”
Again, yikes. 

Schools are not industrial producers of meat widgets. They are not fast food chains. They are not performing a highly standardizable task that can be deskilled to the point that any shmoe can be quickly and effectively trained to perform their task without deviation. And all of this is true because A) students are not products and B) the "customers" are not just their parents or their future employers but every single person who will ever cross paths with them directly or indirectly, which is why we have such a hard time deciding exactly what outputs we really want.

Once again, I will argue till death that some guardrails and some standards are absolutely necessary for schools and teachers and students, but the perfect one-size-fits-all standardization that some folks dream of, the kind of standardization that makes Chick-fill-A successful for the part of the population that chooses to eat there-- that kind of rigid standardization will not work for education because we are dealing with human beings and not slices of breaded chicken and chopped up potatoes. 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Kindergarten Readiness Is In Trouble

The US General Accounting Office has a new study declaring that fewer than half of students were actually ready for kindergarten-- which is just one way of looking at the data.

For their report, the GAO reviewed 11 studies that looked at kindergarten readiness; the GAO also looked at kindergarten readiness in five states as measured by the states' kindergarten entry assessment (KEA). The five states were Connecticut, Florida, Kentucky, Maryland, and Ohio.

Some of what they found was unsurprising. Publicly funded preschool enrollment "positively affected students’ kindergarten readiness in literacy, math, or both." Also, the highest rates of kindergarten readiness were found in "students who were Asian, White, or not economically disadvantaged." Districts with lower poverty rates have higher rates pf kindergarten readiness in four of the five states. Zero surprises here.

The marquee finding in the report is that the majority of kindergarten students were not ready for kindergarten, as measured by the states' KEA. 

The states cannot really be compared to each other because each has its own KEA. But each shows a range of students with a median percentage of kindergarten-ready students that falls below 50%. The reports breaks some of that readiness down into categories (again, varying by state), but it still doesn't look good.

The conclusion is alarming-- most of the littles aren't ready for kindergarten.

But wait a minute.

If I'm teaching and a test comes back with a greater than 50% failure rate, I have a couple of choices for explanations:

A) I didn't do my teaching job very well

B) The test isn't a very good test

C) I gave the test before the students were ready to take it, and whose fault is that, exactly

Every time one someone starts chicken littling about kindergarten students not being ready, I flash back to talk I saw education expert Yong Zhao give at the Network for Public Education convention in 2015, during which he pointed out that we should not ask if the five year old is ready for school, but instead ask if school is ready for the five year olds.

The average, median five year old does not meet your standards for height, then your standards are wrong. If the average, median five year old does not meet your standards for kindergarten readiness, then your standards for kindergarten readiness are wrong. They are misaligned. Or maybe they're  aligned only for littles from a particular demographic. Maybe you're still stuck in that Common Core induced push-down of standards where kindergarten is the new first grade and infancy is new preschool and fetuses should be learning their letters and numbers in utero. 

If the majority of littles in your state are not "ready," then that is on you-- not them, not their parents. It is the institution's job to be ready for the children, not vice versa. You can say that you wish five year olds knew basic algebra and wrote in complete paragraphs, but they are who they are, and you have to take them as they are.

So yeah-- the results of this study show that somebody is not ready for these children tp enter kindergarten. But it's not the children.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Cyberselfish: A Prescient Look At The World of Tech

Paulina Borsook was a journalist covering Northern California tech culture since the 1980s. In 2000, she produced Cyberselfish, a sharply written critique of that culture, a book that has this year been reprinted and wow, what a piece of work, because Borsook was way, way ahead of her time.

Borsook tears into a culture that is hugely libertarian and male and marked by characteristics that will seem familiar to current readers.

She writes about a culture of technolibertarians who are wildly self-important, convinced that they are doing super-important work and therefor should be A) revered by the common herd that is so beneath them and B) unhampered by any sort of regulation and restriction. She writes that 

the myth of the solo entrepreneur is embedded deep in the Silicon Valley psyche, a myth only partially grounded in reality. And like many myths, this one ignores the larger culture it springs from. The (male) alone-on-his-search-to-earn-his-manhood isn't exactly how it really works.

This culture comes with many less-than-awesome features, like "high tech's curious nyah-nyah-nyah-I've-got-mine-so-screw-you orientation to the world." That and a belief that "the market will prevail" and so regulations are neither necessary nor desirable.

So much of this is recognizable from the world of early-21st-century ed reform-- a school should be run by a visionary CEO who is unhampered by rules and regulations (unnecessary because the market will decide whether he has succeeded or not). 

There is of course also a faith in computers themselves. At one point, Borsook points out that because computers change so quickly, and white and blue work uses computers, therefor those jobs must also change quickly and the enterprises and industries they are part of must also change. (See also: every reformster argument that education has to change radically Right Now.) She also connects this to a techno "joy of obsolescence."

Borsook also describes how these technotitans feel put upon and victimized, demanding freedom from any sort of intervention as well as a less-explicit insistence that folks recognize that these tech overlords really ought to be revered and in charge. So powerful, and yet so brittle.

But why is this group, so privileged, so poised for flight in any direction-- to get a well-compensated job, to hire top-drawer lawyers, to live in horse country or exurbia away from urban unrest, to shelter assets, to flee-- so flipped about the possibility of being messed with?

She writes about techno philanthropy's discomfort with "squishy stuff and the intangibles that can't be reduced to formulae or program,' and its disinterest in the care of people "who do not represent problems to be solved." 

Techno dollars do, she notes, go to K-12 education. The cynical motivation, she notes, would be the idea that "you gotta catch 'em/brainwash them when they're young-- or they won't be good workers in their cubicles, won't be good purchasers of your latest rev (that is, version of software), won't have formed the strong brand loyalty you want them to have." These tech folks also imagined knowledge as simple retrieval of data.

They had other education ideas, too. Kim Polese, a then-CEO of software company Marimba, proposed at an Al Gore-hosted confab, a piece of vaporware called Dashboard. Dashboard would allow parents to log on to their tv to get the latest stats on their child's performance and even send notes to the teacher. That particular program did not materialize, but the general concept has certainly done well since.

At times it's stunning what Borsook spotted in the late 1990s. She reports a 1994 presentation that presaged AI agents and tech overlords who envisioned a "happy land of a world serviced by agents and amused by content freed from dependency on" other human's ideas, a land of "a land of individuals isolated from the need for contact with other human beings and, relievedly, no longer reliant upon them."

Anachronisms crop up at times. She mentions Sports Illustrated as a publication "thriving" when cut loose from its parent corporation. Yahoo is a new startup. And social media is nowhere in sight.

I've just scratched the surface here. The book provides a clear and sharply observed of tech overlord culture that is in many ways sharper and clearer than most observers right now. It's a worthwhile read and really brings into focus some of the culture and attitudes that we are dealing with right now (and her writing brings lots of bright-edged sass). I recommend grabbing a copy. I'll leave you with this clip from her closing argument.

I don't believe that a culture that presents itself as being the One True Way of the future, but which in so many ways embodies the worst of the past-- where human values and, ultimately, people, count for less than machines-- is one that is cause for rejoicing.

IN: A Tale of Charter Fraud.

At one point, Indiana Virtual School and Indiana Virtual Pathways Academy were two of the largest cyber-charters in Indiana. But that turns out to have been part of a huge case of fraud, and almost a decade after the original fleecing of Indiana taxpayers, some of the fraudsters running the operation are facing jail time.

Phillip Holden, Thomas Stoughton, Percy Clark and Christopher King managed to steal almost $45 million from taxpayers. 

The schools, founded in 2011, were going great guns by 2016, but a Chalkbeat story by Shaina Cavazos  in 2017 showed some of the cracks in the school's supposed success. For one thing, the school only had one teacher for every 222 teachers. It only graduated 61 out of 900 seniors. And while it was raking in the money, Cavazos found that only 10% of the state funds hoovered up by the school were going toward instruction (a massive difference from other cyber-charters in the state). The other almost-90 percent was going to "support services," including firms that were owned and run by people who were also running IVS.

Indiana Virtual School was, in fact, a textbook case of self-dealing for fun and profit. The state handed millions to the school, then the school's leaders handed millions to companies that they themselves owned. Thomas Stoughton was founder of the school, and he hired AlphaCom Inc., another company he founded and owned. Cavazos also found that IVS hired a company owned by Stoughton's son.

Also, in 2017, after IVS received an F from the state, they then created IVPA to avoid losing their charter.

In 2019, Daleville Community Schools, the virtual schools' oversight board, revoked its charter. The board of directors quit, and the cyber-charters were shut down even as the US Attorney's office issued a subpoena to collect evidence about the schools.

The schools were in big trouble because, not satisfied with the self-dealing scheme they were already running, the four individuals named above had also cooked up a scheme to boost the schools' enrollment with students not actually attending the school. The investigation and court cases focused on 2016-2018, but it seems unlikely that those were the only years fraud went on.

The prosecutors of the case found that thousands of students never logged in or were re-enrolled after they had left the school. The school did not, as law requires, unenroll students who never show up. They went ahead and enrolled students who had never finished their applications to the school. The court found that the school enrolled at least one student after he had died. 

The four enrolled these non-attending students, collected taxpayer dollars from the state, handed those dollars off to the sweetheart subcontractors, and pocketed the money. Federal charges followed.

Clark, Stoughton, and King pled guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud. Holden was convicted of wire fraud and conspiracy to commit same just last week; his lawyer has called Holden a fall guy who didn't make any money from the scheme. Clark appears to have scored a measly $1.3 million. They are all supposed to be paying the money back; I hope nobody's holding their breath waiting for that to happen.

A few lessons from this not-unusual tale of charter fraud and malfeasance.

One, magical free market forces did not take care of this. In fact, the state of Indiana did not take care of this. It took a combination of journalism and federal investigators to shut this down. Keep that in mind the next time a charter fan is explaining that too much regulation and oversight will stifle the awesome innovative powers of charter entrepreneurs. 

Two, it took a decade to bring some justice to this situation. A decade! Some of the students who were enrolled in this scam are now nearly thirty years old. 

Three, the free market did not take care of this. Yes, I said that already, but it is worth saying at least twice. School choice without any regulation or oversight is simply an invitation to fraud and abuse, and there will always be folks willing to accept that invitation. Students and taxpayers deserve some protection from these guys, not a belated attempt at sort-of-justice.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

My District Finds a New Use for AI

I want to hope that my local school district is the only district that has landed on this bad idea, but it probably isn't. So we'd better talk about it.

The big focus on a recent meeting was the teacher contract negotiations, so even the newspaper missed one feature of the 2.5 hour meeting until later, when the reporter circled back to the part of the meeting where the board checked out the annual year in review report as well as goals for the current year. Then comes this sentence. 

Both presentations were compiled and read by artificial intelligence.

I had also missed this. I am not able to attend meetings on Mondays, so I check out the video record, but I had honestly noped out on this one before the report appeared.  

It is spectacularly absurd. The AI opens with "I am so excited to be guiding you through this tonight" in a pleasant female voice. Of course, the AI is not "excited" in any sense of the word, but companies understand that AI is easier to market if you build it to mimic human behavior. The presentation includes lots of imitation human presenter tweaks. Starting a new section-- "Let's get into it" as if the AI and the humans in the room are a "we". On attendance-- "because, let's face it, you can't teach a student who isn't sitting in the classroom." 

And there are attempts to imitate an emotional affect as well. On the improvement in attendance-- "the sheer scope of the improvement here is absolutely incredible," says the computer program that is incapable of believing anything. "You've got to see what happened at [one other school]. This is a real game-changer." The AI is really mimicking an engaged human presenter who has an actual presence or investment in the district. Introducing another section-- "I want you to just take a second and absorb this." The AI is of course incapable of wanting anything, and if I were a board member I would bristle at the notion of doing what a program "wants" me to do. 

The AI also mimics human tone of voice with lots of heartfelt emphasis on various portions, and salting it with little touches like "kind of" and extra modifiers. 

The strategic goals for 2026-27 were also presented by AI, but for whatever reason, that AI was a male voice that says, among other things, "As your administrative leadership team, we know it is our absolute duty..." and I am wondering which position on the team the AI is filling. It also closes with "I want to leave you with this..." even though there is no "I' and it does not "want." But generally this AI does not have its human mimicry turned quite so far as the first. Still, why is it here at all?

Why? Why? Why? Why is this report not being presented by the administration? I emailed the board members and superintendent and received no response (and to be fair, they've got their hands full with a couple of other issues we won't get into here). 

You can argue that my objections are petty and nit-picky, that there's nothing wrong with using some automation to spice up what would be a boring parade of data. Why not have the reports read out in a personable and engaging manner? And afterwards district leaders can post the AI presentation straight to the website (which they have). Sure, you could do all of that with live humans, but if you can use AI to polish it up and save some trouble, why wouldn't you? What's the big deal?

Well, it's a big deal to me to know that the school district is being run by humans. Maybe I am just getting worked up over cosmetics, but I have some serious objections to this use of AI.                        

First, the AI doesn't get interrupted by questions for clarification. For example-- One of the goals that the district "achieved" was to improve the school climate as measured by referrals handled by the office. Those numbers went down, which can mean one of two things--1) the actual incidents of misbehavior decreased or 2) the reports of such incidents decreased. Place your bets on which is more likely. It's a point that ought to be discussed, but there is no interrupting the AI. There were a couple of questions after the presentation, but nothing got into the meat of the presentation. 

AI, like any canned presentation, offers no opportunity for discussion, question, or dialogue.

Second, it puts some distance between the administration and at least one really questionable choice. After making noise about the drops in math scores, the AI gets to the "solution." 

But listen, the district isn't just sitting still with this data. Looking ahead to the upcoming 2026-2027 school year, they are rolling out a revised schedule that includes a double period block of math instruction for all students in grades six through eight. 

This, extrudes the AI, is "a bold move to tackle the data." It is not. It is an old idea that was widely tried earlier in this century and which failed. Not only did it fail, but the AI fails to discuss what portion of the students' education will be cut in order to give them double math (nor does it mention any hiring of additional math teachers to handle the doubled load). We've seen this movie before-- students lose history, science, arts, music, study halls, other enrichment opportunities for an initiative that barely moves the needle if at all. In fact, this exact idea was attempted in this very same district years ago. It did way more harm than good.

But you will notice that nobody in administration has to own this bad idea. "The district" in the form of an unspecified "they" is rolling this out. No administrator stood up to make a case for this. 

AI is like the ultimate passive voice. "This thing just happened!" 

Third, this is a lousy example to set for students. One of the major challenges of classroom teachers right now is convincing young humans that it's a bad idea to use AI as a shortcut for getting their work done. And here are the leaders of the school district, using AI as a shortcut for getting their work done (and to any teachers who are also doing it, you knock it off, too). This is not AI being used to extend or augment human capabilities; it's just AI used to outsource the work that humans are perfectly capable of doing. How would you explain to a student that what the administration did was somehow different from having AI write your science or English paper?

I don't imagine for a second that my district is unique; I expect that some AI company has identified school administration as a market for this sort of cognitive outsourcing. It's easy to let it go because it can seem like a small thing, but if a school district is going to prioritize human beings and human relationships, then that priority should be expressed throughout the district's actions. At the very least, if you are going to use AI, use it transparently and honesty and don't cloak it with mimicry that let's it suggest human attributes that it absolutely does not have. So I'm going to go ahead and shake my aged fist at this particular cloud and encourage my district (and yours) to do better. 

Monday, November 9, 2026

Teacher Autonomy and Fads

Let me bring up the same old argument, and then let me completely sidestep it for another critical solution.

This morning I ran into another discussion of why American teachers get wrapped up in so many fads and why aren't they better grounded in scientific learning principles. There is always some blame directed at the US fetishization of teacher autonomy, and the counter-argument is that teacher autonomy is needed, at a minimum, to allow teachers to resist being forced to implement the latest fad that some administrator decided is a must-do.

There are many long, complicated responses to this debate that I could unleash (and I have), not the least of which is that great truth about teaching-- you need a balance of whatever you're talking about. Teachers need flexibility and a certain amount of autonomy, but they also need guardrails and direction.

But never mind that (for the moment). Let me suggest one other huge change that would help.

Teachers should be in charge of the teaching profession.

Look at the medical world. If I want to start a program to educate new members of a medical profession, I have to get that program certified by a board composed by members of that profession. Graduates who want to enter the profession have to clear certification from groups composed of members of that profession. At every step, for every gate that is kept, the gatekeeper is someone from that profession.

But teaching? If I want to start a K12 teacher prep program, all I have to do is convince some bureaucrats. And I can staff that teacher prep program with people who haven't seen the inside of a K12 classroom in decades, or even ever. My professional certification depends on testing created by people who are not actual teachers. 

At every gate, the gatekeepers are people who are not teachers. Research, published teaching materials, curricular programs, government oversight-- we just accept as a normal part of the profession that absolutely everything outside the classroom is under the control of people who are not actually teachers. We even figured out a way to make the problem worse-- run Teach for America products through a classroom for two years so that we could elevate people who aren't teachers but pretend to be teachers (even though they never even intended to be teachers) can sit in positions of power over the profession. And as a cherry on top, we get plenty of voices denigrating teacher expertise or dismissing teacher concerns as just "putting the concerns of adults over those of children" or just the noise of a special interest group.

If I think I've got a great new idea about how to conduct brain surgery, I have to convince an actual brain surgeon to try it, and if that surgeon thinks it's a good idea, they still have to convince other actual brains surgeons. If brain surgery were teaching, I could just convince some legislator that my idea is great and they should pass a law mandating my technique be used by all surgeons.

Hell, we can see how it would look as we currently have a wave of powerful amateurs harassing the medical profession and sneering at science. So fads, wacky notions, and ideas that "make sense" if you've got a thimbleful of medical wisdom in your brain. 

It's not going well for health care, but it's a normal day in education. With few education gatekeepers, every kind of fad can slide through, with classroom teachers left to sort through it all. Why do teachers value autonomy so much? Because they can't trust the wide array of people who want to tell them exactly, precisely how to do their jobs. 

None of this is meant to suggest that useful teacher partners can't come from unexpected places. Grown-ups transitioning from other fields. TFA products who choose to stay and really enter into the profession. Scholars and education professors and even thinky tank people who have thoughtfully studied the field and the profession. Some of these folks can turn out to serious allies in the work-- but it's up to the teacher to sort them out on her own. The networks that teachers build aren't just to help them figure out best practices, but to help them figure out who they can trust.

Dozens of various ideas about how to do the job, layered on top of the many stakeholders who also have their own priorities and preferences. Teachers want their arms and legs free to dance with and around the many partners and obstacles that come with the job.

Not every teacher is going to make the best use of autonomy, just as some teachers become too attached to ineffective instructional ideas. And nobody tells you that this is going to be part of the job, that you may have to rebel against your administration or your government or your old college teachers, that you may have to figure it out on your own.

Is it possible to create a professional ecosystem, a gaggle of gatekeepers who filter out fads? I don't know. I know that a website of "what works" curated by non-teachers is not useful. I know that professional groups that exist outside the school walls and so must simultaneously try to catch the ears of both other teachers and policymakers offer only a little help. And yes, there are teachers who really revel and joy in the vast unfiltered system. 

But if your question is "Why so many fads" or "Why don't good practices get more traction" or "Why do teachers care so much about autonomy," the questions share part of an answer-- the education space is a big pool with a hundred different unfiltered hoses pouring into it, leaving classroom teachers to try to swim around and exercise their professional judgement about who or what to hold onto. 




Sunday, November 8, 2026

ICYMI: Blue Wave Edition (11/8)

Honestly, I didn't believe it was going to happen, but here we are. Now let's see what it means for education. In the meantime, there's plenty to read this week.

EdChoice is Over

Stephen Dyer explains why Ohio's big fat voucher program, already ruled unconstitutional in lower courts, is likely to be in big trouble now.

Anger over GOP education agenda helped fuel Democratic sweeps in Texas, advocates say

NBC news notices one of the major issues in Texas was the GOP's education plans. Give a shout to Jennifer Berkshire, who has been saying this all along.

Supreme Court Leaning Yes on Publicly Financed Discrimination Against 4-Year-Olds

I've been covering this story over at Forbes.com and I suspect people aren't paying nearly enough attention to this case which could decide that not only should taxpayers fund religious schools, but those schools should be exempt from anti-discrimination laws. Madiba Dennie sums up the day of oral arguments, and it's not looking great.

The Catholic Church Has Taken “Do Unto Others” in the Wrong Direction

Education Adam Laats provides some historical perspective to the case. 

Dear American Parent: You’re Welcome!

Jen Jennings, in the New York Times, with a fairly awesome Alexandra Petri-esque take of life for parents under school voucher "freedom."

Should You Outsource Your Child’s Birthday Party to AI?

John Warner's take on that disastrously clueless Marissa Mayer interview. Should you use AI to do the hard, hard work of humaning? Maybe not?

You know how sometimes you don't really want to watch a movie, but you watch the "Everything Wrong With..." so you have an idea of what was going on (and why you are wise not to watch the actual thing)? That's kind of where I am with Sold A Story. Trevor Aleo and Nick Covington continue their conversations in response to the latest episode.


You can also podcast your way to a better understanding of Direct Instruction with Jennifer Berkshire and Jack Schneider, who cover it over at Have You Heard.


Nancy Bailey takes a look at Direct Instruction and what it overlooks.

Parents Sue Google Over A.I. Safety Risks on School Chromebooks

Another lawsuit over an AI-linked suicide plan. Natasha Singer covers it for the New York Times.

A Letter to Governor Hinojosa: Fixing Texas School Finance

Bruce Baker continues to be on a tear. This time the school finance expert offers advice to the new Texas governor on what to fix about school financing.


Audrey Watters shares a talk she recently delivered-- and it's not about AI, exactly:
Indeed, for all the handwringing about the cognitive dependencies that “AI” might elicit -- now or in the future -- I'd argue that education has already acquiesced an incredible amount of intellectual and pedagogical and operational and political ground to technologies that have cultivated precisely that: a dependency.
A quaint tale of the destruction of Florida’s public schools & what you can do about it

Maybe you don't think of turning to Bruce Baker for witty and whimsical Seussian fables of education, but here it is. "The Whittler" explains how Florida raced to the bottom.

What the Blue Blowout Means for Federal Education

Rick Hess shows what the blue wave might mean from the reformster side of education.

Washington Loves Baby Photo Ops, but Its Budget Tells Another Story

Bruce Lesley takes a look at how little money DC puts where its mouth noises about The Children issue forth.

Blue Wave and Education Reform: Texas Edition

The privatization crowd is sad that Texas "ambitious ed reform" laboratory could take a hit. Paul Thomas brings the data to show that Texas wasn't doing all that well. 

How Will Tuesday’s Midterm Election Shape Public Education Policy?

Jan Resseger takes us through some of the post-election commentary about whatever is going to happen next.

NYC Parent Accuses Son’s Elementary And Middle Schools Of Negligent Grade Inflation — But The Data Suggests Otherwise

Gary Rubinstein has been seeing that NY Post story about the mom complaining that her son can't do math despite his good grades. Gary has his doubts, so he looks at some numbers.

Questions to ask your principals and School Leadership Teams about privacy, AI, ed tech use and screens

This post from Class Size Matters may be intended for NYC families, but it fits anywhere. Great questions to ask your administration the next time they're launching the Next Big Tech Thing

3 Habits Students Can Develop to Find Credible Online Resources

You've probably heard these before, but they're worth revisiting with students. Or at least the students who are looking past the AI summary at the top of their results. Michael Yell at Edutopia.

EIGHTH REPORT: You Can’t See Everything at Alpha

Ben Riley is still cranking out reports on Alpha Schools; this one looks at the organization chart. Who's really in charge of what?

I’m Shocked, Shocked! A Reformed Lobbyist on Whisper Campaigns

Fascinating look at how our tech overlords manage campaigns against their critics (e.g. Jonathan Haidt)

At Forbes.com, I looked at that Supreme Court case threatening yet more bricks in the church state wall. 

I know this seems like it must be a joke, but trust me-- after a minute or two you are going to forget you're listening a bunch of harmonicas. And I do love Rhapsody in Blue.

\
Subscribe to my newsletter. Free now and always. 

Saturday, November 7, 2026

This Is Not How It Should Work

This is my politics rant. I promise-- once it's out of my system, I'll move on. 

It is great that Democrats swept the table this week. It's delightful that places like Texas now have Democratic leaders who actually support public education and might roll back some of the crap that Greg Abbott forced on Texans. It is beyond special that a Democratic Congress might care enough to undo the federal voucher program. And I welcome a batch of Democrats who don't try to make education the solution to every economic ill in the country (thereby giving themselves an excuse to do not-a-damn-thing). 

But damn-- this is not how it is supposed to work.

"Education is not a political issue" has been the motto of a couple decades worth of politicians trying to make it a political issue. From using political maneuvers to force states to impose a Big Standardized Test, to political maneuvers to twist school district arms with an unreachable deadline ("Everyone above average by 2014") to the use of that political leverage to force Common Core and RttT into schools to every state legislature that said, "Never mind what the public wants-- we are going to slide vouchers into law by whatever political trick we can get away with."

Education has been a political orphan for a long time, but that doesn't mean it can't be used as a political football, and while I'm happy that some Good Politicians have come to rescue education, I am also deeply pissed that Good Politicians have come to rescue education, because it just underlines our political football status, and the trouble with being a football is that you just get kicked back and forth and back and forth and back and forth.

Libertarian comedy writer P. J. O'Rourke describes politics as "the business of getting power and privilege without possessing merit." That's particularly apropos with education, which is repeatedly besieged by amateurs who consider themselves experts when they don't even have enough actual knowledge to tip a Dunning-Kruger scale. And yet, they are sure just what teachers ought to be forced to do, and for the past few decades, they have infiltrated legislatures across the country.

The infuriating examples of unearned political power are everywhere. Marcus Luther picked out a quote from Emily Hanford's newest podcast case for Make Teachers Do This:
I thought about being a teacher in my early 20s and I had a friend who was teaching in New Orleans, and a bunch of her third graders couldn't read, and she was supposed to design all of her own lessons. And I thought to myself, where would you even start? It was such a stressful job. It was basically impossible, and she eventually quit teaching, as a lot of people do, because we make this job too hard. 
The friend was of course a Teach For America product, so I might suggest part of what made the job hard was that she only received five weeks of training, from other TFA people who also had no formal training for teaching. But twenty-something Hanford could look at this and confidently determine that the job was just too hard and has carried that forward to her campaign to fix teaching by getting legislatures to mandate proper techniques (just like she did with reading). 

There are going to be a gazillion thought pieces on the general theme of "What education can expect from Democrats" and I dream of a day when the answer is "Leave schools alone and let teachers do their jobs." Should there be guardrails, accountability and transparency? Absolutely (and for all schools getting taxpayer money). But I wish the age of micromanagement would end. 

You can tell me that it's privilege and naive to want education not to be in the thrall of politics, but I'm old enough to remember life before Americans became convinced that every damned thing should be subject to politics, that politics should carry more weight than humanity or just letting people live their lives (and so, politicians should get to carry deciding votes about everything).

Schools do not operate in a vacuum, and the schoolhouse will always be set up downhill from society. But school personnel should not have to wait to see the outcome of each election in order to find out how they're going to do their job. I'm glad this election went our way, but I am sorry that schools have to care so much about it. 

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Let's Have Some Education Reform

It is past time for education reform.

The privatization crowd hasn't made a lot of noise about the "status quo" in a while, because currently much of the status quo is what they forced on education. The new status quo is loaded with bad, toxic ideas; some are now old enough that the Duncan and DFER crowd waste our time opining about the days when their bad ideas were shiny and new and not dusty and disproven.

American education has never been perfect, has (like the country) been on a long journey to try to live up to its own ideals-- and the journey doesn't always lead directly forward. So what reforms do we need right now to move education forward?

End Test-centric Schooling

It is time to end the tyranny of the Big Standardized Test, which warps and distorts the shape of education. We do test prep drill instead of full, deep, rich studies. We judge every school expenditure, every education program, every idea by one question-- will this raise scores on a mediocre multiple-choice math and reading test given once per year. 

We have convinced a generation of teachers and students that the only real job of schools is to get students to score well on the Big Standardized Test. What a cramped, meager vision of education. 

If we absolutely can't quit the test, then at the very barest minimum, we have to remove every last stake from it. That includes never again using it as a proxy for "student achievement," which is probably impossible because education journalists and education researchers are so addicted to that sloppy shorthand. 

How will we know how students are doing? That's a tough question, but my real answer is we don't know all that much now, because the sliver of data produced by the BS Test is tiny and certainly disproportionate to the amount of damage that focusing on the test does to education. Start by asking the big questions, like "what is education for" and then start trying to figure out how to measure that instead of asking "What can we measure and reduce to simple data, and how can we convince ourselves that that's what's really important."

Regulate Choice

Choicers have insisted every step of the way that charters and vouchers should operate free from government oversight and regulation because the magical free market will take care of it. We are far enough into the experiment that this assurance is bunk. Furthermore, children only get one shot at school-- it is unacceptable to have to tell a student "Sorry. Turns out we didn't know what we were doing and your last few years of school were a waste." Choicers are going to say, "But bad public schools do that, too" and maybe they do, but you don't accept it there, so why accept it for choice schools.

And that goes double for voucher schools. If you want to get voucher money, your doors will be open to all students, you won't discriminate, and you will meet the basic educational standards of the state. If you want to be free of government oversight and regulation, then don't take vouchers and remain a fully independent private school.

And education savings accounts should also have oversight. The kind of guardrails that Arizona voters wanted in order to prevent the kind of fraud and abuse that Arizaon's program typified. 

Taxpayers deserve accountability and transparency for how their education dollars are spent, not assurances that magical free market forces will make everything okay. 

Worried about parental choice? It is not necessary to unleash an unregulated free market to give them choice, and it is absolutely necessary to have oversight and regulation to protect the interests of the rest of society. Spoiler alert: parents are not by any stretch of the imagination the only stakeholders in education.

End Teacher Micro-management

The technoreformsters of the modern era have dreamed of a world in which classrooms are teacher-proof and teaching requires only slightly more qualifications than a fast food fry cook. The result is continued micro-management of teachers and a deprofessionalized profession. Teachers should work with support and guidance in a system that is built on trust. 

Do not try to legislate curriculum and instruction. Do not decide that whatever program a senator just heard on a podcast should be turned into a legislative mandate. By all means, advocate for better and better curriculum and instruction, but do it by making the case to teachers as if they were, in fact, education professionals, and don't just try to force them to follow the flavor of the month.

Let teachers teach. Yes, hold them accountable to professional standards. But let them do their damned jobs. Give them the tools and support they need. Make the profession attractive again with decent levels of pay and autonomy linked to power and responsibility. 

And in connection with this--

Fix the teacher pipeline

Look, the teacher training pipeline has never been great, but these days its even worse. It has always suffered from college professors whose familiarity with K-12 classrooms runs from limited to non-existent. Now add to that education departments that are teaching future teachers that their job is mainly test prep. 

I've talked about better approaches to teacher training many times. They programs should emphasize content knowledge, a big pedagogical toolbox, and lots of support in the early stages. 

Really fix the administrator pipeline

Show me a school with problems, and I will show you a school with a bad administrator. Administrative jobs are the least attractive in education-- all the responsibility and little power. So maybe they just attract a lot of the wrong people. But we don't talk about this issue nearly enough. 

Fix the research pipeline

So much education is junk-- or indistinguishable from junk. And working teachers don't have the time to sort through the mountain of stuff. I sure wish there was a way for meaningful, useful research to get to classroom teachers. 

Funding

Can we bring an end to the American desire to fund education on the cheap? A tough haul, but still a reform that is needed. Fund so that districts can compete for top teachers. Fund so that districts can lower class sizes and provide more supports for teachers and students. Fund so that outdated facilities can be brought up to speed. Fund so that some students aren't attending what everyone knows is the poor, run down school. 

Talk about what education is for

This is not a question we will ever answer definitively for all of the country. But our failure to talk about it all has allowed Certain Folks to plug in their own answer, which appears to be roughly "To generate a stream of data that will allow corporate overlords to better command and select meat widgets to generate profits." This is not a great answer, but we've never discussed it. Nor did we ever discuss "The purpose of school is to generate good scores on the BS Test," so we were just stuck with it.

One of the challenges of the classroom is that you face a hundred different expectations, most unspoken. We should have the conversation and not be afraid that it's a question that can't be settled, because the conversation really matters, and people who want education to suck for Lessers because "those people will just be digging ditches anyway" should have to say so out loud.

Rebuild the social commitment

Part of the conversation we haven't had and part of the effect of the free market choice movement has been to quietly torpedo the societal commitment to educating all children. We need to strengthen that commitment.

It's not a new issue. We can go all the way back to the days after Brown v. Board when a whole lot of folks complained, "What do you mean I have to pay taxes so Black kids can go to school??!!" Part of the free market education project as envisioned by Milton Friedman has always been taking education as a commitment for which society, through government, takes responsibility and turning it into a commodity for which individuals take responsibility. The underlying message of school choice is "If you want an education for your kid, that's a You problem." Vouchers, dressed up as choice and freedom, are a pint-sized payoff to soften the blow (given enough years, I predict they would slowly shrink away entirely).

This is wrong at least two ways. First, it's a shitty, selfish stance, a declaration that I should never be in any way inconvenienced for the benefit of my fellow human. It's an odious ideology. Second, it's impractically short-sighted. Do you really imagine that you will suffer no ill effects if large sectors of society are under-educated? History says you are a dope. In fact, as Adam Laats points out in Mr Lancaster's System, part of the origin of our system is a societal concern about too many unschooled youths running about. 

This is one of the cheapest asks on my list. It just takes some people in leadership positions to talk about how we are all of us stakeholders in education and we all benefit from a well-educated citizenry. It just takes some leaders to talk about how we have a collective responsibility to make it possible for every child to unlock their potential to the benefit of not only them, but all of us. Lord, how long has it been since we had leaders talking like that? Instead we get noise about how education will fix inequity (so nobody else in government needs to work on the problem) and education will help individuals make more money and/or be more useful to future employers or talk about how schools must serve parents because the students are their parents' chattel. 

Screw all of that. We all pay for education because we all benefit from education. Because the most fundamental feature of a nation is that we take care of the other people in that nation. Because no nation ever ran into trouble because of too much education. Education is the work of helping young humans find and embrace their best and truest selves even as they achieve greater understanding of what it means to be fully human in the world. I want to hear leaders talk like that, and then I want them to craft education policy like they believe it.

Is this an exhaustive list?

Probably not. Feel free to add to it in the comments.

I’ve been starting and restarting this post for a couple of years now, because I believe we need education reform-- as long as we understand that “ed reform” doesn’t mean what it meant ten or twenty years ago. Something just possessed me to finally finish it off today. And I hope the message gets out there.